5 ms·
If only the telcos here weren't so corrupt we could have more municipal fiber projects. Yes I'm looking at you Comcast.
by gigatexal 10y ago
If only the telcos here weren't so corrupt we could have more municipal fiber projects. Yes I'm looking at you Comcast.
- tnuc 10y agoCorrupt? They all follow the law. The problem may be the way the laws get enacted. What might be considered very corrupt in one country is just how business is done in the USA.
- deepnotderp 10y agoFound the Comcast shareholder.... They literally lobby to make the laws.
- chomp 10y agoLobbying is legal though, and is a tool used by charities/public interest advocates as well as big corporations.
- Veratyr 10y agoYes but the difference is that what's called "lobbying" in the US often consists of what most other governments consider "bribery".
- afarrell 10y agoLiteral quid-pro-quo bribery is illegal and people go to jail for it. I get that you are talking about other corrupt phenomena, but we need a different word than bribery because I've run into way too many people who think our corruption problem comes from bribery. We also need a better way for elected officials to be able to tap into citizen expertise rather than just the slice of it which is sponsored by a rent-seeking profit motive.
- cmdrfred 10y agoMake no mistake Citizens United legalized bribery you just have to wink a say it's a "campaign contribution". Everyone involved knows what it really is. Unless you actually believe that the fact that politicians pass laws that are extremely favorable to firms while receiving millions from them is unrelated, if you do I have a bridge for sale.
- afarrell 10y agoCitizens United was not about campaign contributions. It was about whether or not a corporation could use its funds to create materials denouncing (or praising) a candidate for office. Summary: http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/citizens-united-v-federal-election-commission/ http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/citizens-united-v... Full 183 page opinion: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-205.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-205.pdf
- chomp 10y agoSure, I agree with that. The parent should have been more clear on the point they were trying to make. Leaving a exasperated comment about how Comcast lobbies to influence the law doesn't make sense, because everyone on both sides of the broadband debate uses lobbying to their advantage. We don't have politicians who are experts in every field, and they rely on outside help to inform them.
- rayiner 10y agoSource, particularly for the "often" part?
- ersii 10y agoExcuse me, but is it not the lawmakers that are corrupt? They are the ones buying their argument (or taking their cash/benefits) and creating moats (regulatory capture and what not) for them.
- zardo 10y agoCorrupt transactions are corrupt for both parties involved.
- throwaway729 10y ago> What might be considered very corrupt in one country is just how business is done in the USA. The definition of corruption is not dependent upon legal status. The wikipedia article on "Corruption" has an entire (and rather long) section that is entitled "Legal corruption".
- Veratyr 10y ago> Corrupt? They all follow the law. These things are not mutually exclusive, particularly when the corruption has resulted in changes to the law.
- rayiner 10y agoThere are a few places where state laws are getting in the way of municipal fiber, but that really isn't the explanation. After all, why isn't fiber getting built in Palo Alto, San Francisco, San Jose, or Seattle? Is some Philadelphia company really more politically connected on Google, Microsoft, etc.'s home turf? And how do you explain the lack of fiber in Baltimore and Los Angeles? Those cities have been aggressively trying to get someone to build municipal fiber. No state laws are standing in the way. Still, nobody will do it.
- techsupporter 10y agoAll of the explanations are easy: It costs a lot of money to build a physical last-mile network that serves a large number of subscribers. Municipal broadband projects would, rightly (in my opinion), be expected to serve the entire city that's funding such a project but that build out would be expensive. Cities with city-owned electrical systems, like Seattle, can mitigate some of the costs by having their power operator run the physical wires through city-owned conduit. But, let's take Seattle as an example, not every part of the city has city-owned conduit and several discrete parts of the city have buried utilities that aren't even in conduit. All of that work has to be paid for and most large cities have other pressing budget needs. There's a movement in Seattle to get municipal broadband done in Seattle but it is slow-moving because, again, money. (Nothing in Washington State law prohibits a city from running its own Internet/cable/phone system. The RCW that a lot of people, falsely, quote as banning muni broadband in WA only applies to public utility districts. Tacoma has its own municipal system, called Click!, that seems to be well-received.)
- rayiner 10y agoThe same thing is true in Baltimore (and really, most cities). The city has no money--no lobbying needed to preclude municipal broadband.
- 1024core 10y ago> why isn't fiber getting built in San Francisco, Because SF is notoriously corrupt. The city government doesn't give a shit about the citizenry; it's all a question of who can do whom favors and help in their next election. // sf resident