3 ms·
In addition to low taxes, the petroleum industry in the United States is perhaps the most heavily subsidized industry (on both a state and federal level) in the
by eropple 10y ago
In addition to low taxes, the petroleum industry in the United States is perhaps the most heavily subsidized industry (on both a state and federal level) in the country. (Top three, for sure.) At the same time, neither the petroleum industry nor the people driving gas-burners are asked to account for the pollution caused by said gas-burning. The unpaid-for externalities related to cars and gas-powered transit cannot be blurfed away by insisting that the New York Times "hates" cars.
(And that's not getting into the economic questions about the places that are made livable because of the profusion of cars--he namedrops places like Tennessee and Idaho and blah blah blah, but the overwhelming majority of those places are money sinks rather than money sources. As a happy liberal, I'm not against subsidizing economically inefficient lifestyles to some degree--but when they're built inescapably on farting out greenhouse gases at a high rate, I think there's a reason to have a discussion about the policies that encourage them.)
It is a many-faceted problem, but the facets being most steadily ignored are the ones that make the pro-car argument pretty weak.
- Aloha 10y agoMost of those oil companies are huge multi-nationals, wouldn't that (admittedly evil) subsidy benefit the whole world? Roughly 30-40% (depending on which source of numbers you look at) of greenhouse gas emissions are from base load power generation - which is something we can mitigate far more easily than the transportation sector. I believe strongly in building more walkable cities, but I don't want to hang the whole of the greenhouse gas problem on the car.
- ageofwant 10y agoHow would subsidizing multi-nationals benefit the whole world ? Corporate welfare benefits the corporation and that's it. If you wanted "the world" to benefit then help the world. I've always found the argument that helping corporations ultimately benefits some other nebulous beneficiary somewhat vacuous. I believe cargo ships followed by airplanes are the biggest net emitters in the transport sector. Office building are the biggest consumers of non-industrial base-load. So pushing fat broadband pipes to the home could potentially reduce the need for both office buildings and daily commutes. Yes, city density should vastly increase. I would like to see the vast sprawling urban deathscape replaced by massive tower cities surrounded by mostly native parklands, interconnected by underground trains and fat broadband pipes. Should you need to leave your comfy digs you ride the elevator or the train.