4 ms·
To clarify a bit: When the parent comment says "isn't good for HN", he's saying that it doesn't meet the basic criteria in the HN Guidelines of something "that
by greenyoda 10y ago
To clarify a bit: When the parent comment says "isn't good for HN", he's saying that it doesn't meet the basic criteria in the HN Guidelines of something "that good hackers would find interesting".[1] Writing a list of terse statements without any explanation or examples (like "the navigation and actions should match the target user’s mental models") isn't very useful or convincing to the reader.
Also, at the bottom of the article you say you're trying to recruit a designer. You may want to consider what kind of message this article sends to prospective employees.
To answer the question "does flagging affects reach of my future content I share here?" - No, flagging just affects a single submission (by decreasing its prominence or killing it).
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sharma_pradeep 10y agoThanks @greenyoda for pitching in, I have published another one after removing the objectionable words. https://medium.com/@pradeep_io/7-important-lessons-for-a-designer-834227a7f42c https://medium.com/@pradeep_io/7-important-lessons-for-a-des... Does it make a better submission? About not writing explanation, I did had the urge to write in the explanations in the article itself. But I believe making it concise and open ended is better for a discussion to listen to different perspectives. Please do let me know your point of view on the same, would love to discuss more.
- greenyoda 10y agoAccording to the Guidelines, the article itself needs to be interesting, independent of any discussion. If the article is not interesting, people probably won't upvote it and there will be no discussion because nobody will see it.
- brudgers 10y agoRight. That's why the number of tweets that make the front page of Hacker News closely approximates zero.
- minimaxir 10y agoThat's not a good counterexample; Tweets are sometimes the canonical source of news (which HN prefers), and news articles are just verbose blogspam of the tweet. (I believe twitter.com is a penalized domain, which I disagree with.)
- brudgers 10y agoIf Twitter is penalized on Hacker News, then it might be a relevant example in this context, i.e. the nature of Hacker News as implemented.
- minimaxir 10y agoYes, thanks for the clarification.