2 ms·
Repeats the standard "encourages diversity of opinion" message that is simply not true. The electoral college system undermines that as you only need minority s
by olliej 10y ago
Repeats the standard "encourages diversity of opinion" message that is simply not true. The electoral college system undermines that as you only need minority support in the correct locations, and gives excessive weight to areas with lower populations. Areas with lower populations are inherently more homogeneous in terms of beliefs/political opinions etc (see the overwhelming majority of votes in one direction in states with lower population).
That said, even the "gives smaller states a voice" is nonsense as the goal of geographic representation is explicitly provided by the senate. Seats in the senate are provided on a state basis, not a population basis. The _only_ portion of the US government that has any semblance of a democracy in the traditional sense is congress which is intended to be proportional to population size. However the ability for political parties to vigorously gerrymander kind of reduces that.
More opinionated: A dual vote system: party vote + individual member vote does a good job of breaking gerrymandering and is also a provably more fair method of voting, but i'm sure that every elected official that benefits from it will push back against it because "the founders!"