2 ms·
> Pencils and paperclips break all the time. Even in areas where safety of life is an issue - popularly assumed to be the sole province of engineers - failures
by twic 10y ago
> Pencils and paperclips break all the time. Even in areas where safety of life is an issue - popularly assumed to be the sole province of engineers - failures still occur absent any negligence on the part of engineers.
Reliability of software is not like reliability of a machine, or building.
Machines and buildings are made of matter, and so have uncontrollable variation, and wear out over time. Everything made of matter fails eventually; it's part of the engineer's job to trade off reliability and cost.
Software is made of bits. The only reason it fails (cosmic rays and other negligible intrusions of matter aside) is defects in design.
Do you really get mechanical or civil engineers saying "yeah, we expect there are a few fatal flaws in the design, that's just how it goes, we'll build it anyway and ship a fix if customers complain"? Apart from on Kickstarter, I mean.
- zb 10y ago(Author here) > Do you really get mechanical or civil engineers saying "yeah, we expect there are a few fatal flaws in the design, that's just how it goes, we'll build it anyway and ship a fix if customers complain"? Heck yes! (Well, not fatal flaws.) Any product you can think of that has been popular enough to get a second production run probably has had some design flaws corrected. Some of which were probably already known by the time that the first version shipped, and some of which were probably only discovered after real users had it in their hands for a while. > it's part of the engineer's job to trade off reliability and cost. Correct. But the cost includes not only the cost of the artefact but also the cost of the design. The difference with software is that design costs dominate in a way that isn't often the case with physical artefacts.