3 ms·
> Also I can't believe a scientist--who should know better--is trying to define this. We're all philosophers, some are just better than others. The legitimacy
by naasking 10y ago
> Also I can't believe a scientist--who should know better--is trying to define this.
We're all philosophers, some are just better than others. The legitimacy of his argument is not dependent on his formal training, and so using this as a reason to dismiss his argument isn't valid.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agowhere did i dismiss his argument? I said he shouldn't sell "science" to tell this story. This is not science.
- naasking 10y agoInterpretation is part of every scientific theory. Many scientific theories that start exploring a new domain posit working definitions that and change and get refined over time.