4 ms·
This is inaccurate. My country (The Netherlands) officially has no nukes. It is a public secret Volkel airbase near Eindhoven hosts USAF nukes though. Diplomati
by Fnoord 10y ago
This is inaccurate. My country (The Netherlands) officially has no nukes. It is a public secret Volkel airbase near Eindhoven hosts USAF nukes though. Diplomatic cable leaks, as well as a statement by former prime minister Ruud Lubbers in 2013 both confirm there are nukes hosted [1].
Yet in statistics like in this article -among other- the above doesn't count. Not even mentioned. Which leads me to wonder how inaccurate the rest is.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkel_Air_Base https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkel_Air_Base
- sfifs 10y agoI think the article's implication is pretty clear that it's trying to enumerate countries which possess/control nuclear weapons, not stationed. I doubt the political leader of Neatherlands can trigger those American weapons stationed on its territory. During the cold war American weapons were certainly deployed in Europe and elsewhere and some very likely still are.
- jessriedel 10y agoYes, this is all well known. It's called "nuclear sharing" and it involves 6 bases at 5 European countries hosting US bombs. Estimated number of weapons by base: Kleine Brogel (Belgium): 10~20 Büchel (Germany): >=20 Volkel (Netherlands): 10~20 Aviano (Italy): 50 Ghedi (Italy): 20~40 Incirlik (Turkey): 50~90 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_sharing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_sharing
- AnonymousPlanet 10y agoThis reminds me of when Sarkozy (ostensibly after some post-dinner drinks) offered Merkel access to French nuclear weapons. The offer was politely declined. http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/a-506124.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/a-506124.html The US has nukes stationed in Germany too and some are even meant to be hooked up to German Tornados, should they ever be used in anger. However, that hardly qualifies as them being controlled by Germany. And therefore they, aswell, don't get a place on that list.
- jawbone3 10y agoUnless the pits themseleves are stored outside of the country, there's not more than like a week of engineering work and a quick wet job preventing Germany from having nukes. Forward stationed nuclear weapons obviously increases the risk of nuclear warfare by pure logistical effects, and the risk of weapons going outside the control of the owners, as the coup in Turkey remind us.
- jbmorgado 10y ago> This is inaccurate. My country (The Netherlands) officially has no nukes. It is a public secret Volkel airbase near Eindhoven hosts USAF nukes though. Diplomatic cable leaks, as well as a statement by former prime minister Ruud Lubbers in 2013 both confirm there are nukes hosted [1]. > Yet in statistics like in this article -among other- the above doesn't count. Not even mentioned. Which leads me to wonder how inaccurate the rest is. > [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkel_Air_Base https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkel_Air_Base Yes, but those are NATO nukes stationed in Netherlands owned by the USA. The article is about the owners of the nukes, not where they are at some moment.
- ksk 10y ago>Which leads me to wonder how inaccurate the rest is. Do you apply this principle in any other area of life?
- jawbone3 10y agoA good point. The official reply of course is that the list is concerned with makers of nuclaer weapons, not with where they happen to be situated, even if the latter is also interesting to know. In the more narrow sense of which countries can make nukes, this list is probably broadly accurate, if maybe a bit high on the actual numbers. Beyond the excursion to Cuba, I don't know of USSR weapons going outside of the union border, and I haven't heard of China offering their weapons to another sovereign country, so such a list would mostly differ by naming where the US has plonked down its arsenal, and maybe some former USSR state that opted to keep the weapons that were in its borders at the time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]