3 ms·
I'm not sure I understand where my mistake is. My question is not whether you are "take it or leave it". My question is whether or not there are expectations se
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I'm not sure I understand where my mistake is. My question is not whether you are "take it or leave it". My question is whether or not there are expectations set up when you upload something, anything, to a free site.
I don't think anybody is advocating some sort of half-measure, like bringing a lawsuit or something. My question is about expectations. HackerNews voting doesn't work as I like. So I complain. I'm told it's a free site so stfu (just making this up and using HN as an example). Is it reasonable for me to expect something from HN since I put stuff on there? If I leave my car keys at the front desk at a hotel, I reasonably expect them to take care of them and put them in the safe. This is a reasonable expectation of people who visit a hotel. If I upload naked pictures of me and a chicken to Facebook and make them private, regardless of TOS, should I have that same type of expectation?
More to the point in this case, for a million years mankind has always thought that the list of who his friends were and his memories of interacting with them were an innate part of his being. Nobody could take this from him. Now Facebook is saying that this is property that they can trade in. Which side makes the most sense? And because it is free, does that change the equation?
Make no mistake, I've long thought Facebook was the devil.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=974281 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=974281