4 ms·
Despite how simple the 8008 is compared to modern processors, I wonder if we'll ever see some sort of commercially-available "3D printer for circuits" that woul
by kibwen 10y ago
Despite how simple the 8008 is compared to modern processors, I wonder if we'll ever see some sort of commercially-available "3D printer for circuits" that would be able to reproduce something of its caliber. Such a thing would finally enable truly open computing at every level, which, even if far less capable than high-end processors, would be sufficient for lots of tasks.
- rpearl 10y agoThe processes needed to fabricate silicon are more subtractive than additive.
- kibwen 10y agoIt someone wants to invent a microscale CNC machine to make it happen, I won't complain. :)
- yaakov34 10y agoYou can easily replicate a 4000-transistor microprocessor with the lowest-end FPGA for a few dollars - cheaper than any 3D-printing process for silicon that I can imagine. It would, of course, also be reprogrammable, making it very cheap for prototypes and experiments.
- kibwen 10y agoFrom a security perspective, how feasible is it for a state-level actor to usefully backdoor a FPGA? I imagine that part of the appeal of personally-fabricated hardware is that, if you validate the design, you have greater assurance about the code executing on your machine. Sort of like the difference between compiling from source and trusting a binary blob (though, just like compilers can be backdoored, I imagine there are theoretical attacks involving subverting the fab itself...).
- yaakov34 10y agoSure. FPGAs, or any IC, could contain subversive/backdoor hardware placed there by a sophisticated actor. For that matter, so could ostensibly passive components like connectors, ports, flat ribbon cables... now that we have sophisticated circuits that can be powered by stray magnetic waves (RFID and its advanced friends), so can components not connected to power, such as cases, clips, screws. It is a fascinating thing to think about, actually, and I don't see how 3D-printing every single thing around you is a realistic solution. And considering that regular color printers (inkjet and laser) have all been backdoored for ages - they print mostly invisible constellations of dots into every page which identify the individual printer - I would say that backdooring a "silicon printer" is also a definite possibility.
- colejohnson66 10y ago> now that we have sophisticated circuits that can be powered by stray magnetic waves (RFID and its advanced friends) The Soviets were doing that back in the 40s[0] [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device)
- Cyph0n 10y agoIt's quite feasible. State of the art FPGA chips are typically manufactured in third party fabs. These are primarily TSMC, GlobalFoundries, and UMC. I'm guessing Intel's acquisition of Altera will result in a more "trustworthy" FPGA. In a nutshell, if a state actor can access the fab, it can insert a backdoor. With circuit design, fully independent verification has not been solved yet. The primary reason is that fabrication, especially at lower process nodes, is extremely complex. So even if you had a "3D IC printer" at home, you still need to trust the manufacturer of that printer, as well as the manufacturer of the key components of the printer. Taking that even further, you need to trust that each of those components was manufactured by a trusted fab. It's turtles all the way down. If I were to design such a printer from scratch, I would have a consortium of known companies oversee the design of the first printer and all of its components in a closed environment with 24/7 surveillance. All circuits would be fabbed using a manual, low volume process. Once the initial printer is complete, all the circuits of subsequent printers would be fabbed using this root printer. There are shortcomings with this technique too, but it's probably the best way to go about doing it (with current tech).
- cfallin 10y agoPeople have replicated silicon fab processes at home -- see e.g. [0] where Jeri Ellsworth makes homemade transistors. Of course the effort she took to do that (while seriously really impressive) probably isn't worthwhile compared to the use of an FPGA if you just want to see your CPU pipeline in Verilog come alive :-) [0] http://hackaday.com/2010/05/13/transistor-fabrication-so-simple-a-child-can-do-it/ http://hackaday.com/2010/05/13/transistor-fabrication-so-sim...
- rwmj 10y agoARM made this announcement about a year ago, not heard much about it since then: https://semiaccurate.com/2015/11/18/arm-charts-path-printed-plastic-chips/ https://semiaccurate.com/2015/11/18/arm-charts-path-printed-...
- pjc50 10y agoEE.SE took a skeptical view of home IC fabrication: https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/67598/how-are-integrated-circuits-fabricated/ https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/67598/how-ar... The short answer is that there is no known way round the very nasty chemistry, requirement for clean room, and so on.
- kuschku 10y agoExcept, there is: Jeri Ellsworth managed to do it at home, without cleanroom. But the chemistry is still very nasty.