4 ms·
The Problem with Griefers
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 10y agoI personally enjoy trolling other players because of the way something so little can lead into such an over-the-top angry response that's odd, because it's people like this who seem the quickest to get upset or abusive when they experience defeat. And i don't mean defeat through being interrupted when they were pursuing some other game objective, but losing in elective 1-on-1 contests (ie where you choose to go battle some random player in an arena). I got into one of those free-to-play games a few years ago and turned out to be really good at it, so I kept advancing without spending any money/subscriber points on upgrades. When I started beating people who had crushed me without mercy as a newbie (but who I had never communicated with) I would reliably receive torrents of abuse for no other reason than that I'd won. As far as I can tell such people don't want to win the game they want to be the winner, so once they've acquired basic competency they devote most of their effort to bullying weaker players rather than improving their competitiveness.
- DanBC 10y agoBut GeneralMinus, for example, probably isn't that good at playing the game. He's excellent at poking exactly the people you mention - the ones who take it so seriously.
- anigbrowl 10y agoThat's the opposite of what I'm saying and I don't know how you drew that conclusion. I'm saying that griefers are precisely the people who get upset when they lose within the gameplay framework. They take up griefing because they are bad losers and griefing gives them a way to 'win' - through the social approval of other griefers, which is reliable enough to slightly outweigh the social payoff from playing unironically. In the griefing game the currency is the negative attentions of non-griefing players, and the primary challenge is not getting banned by the admins. It gives the griefers a sense of power by playing a meta-game whose existence isn't obvious to other players, but without all the hard work of actually setting up and running a game service. They may be crap at whatever the original attractive game is, but they get to be winners in the 'griefing game' by coopting the other players to be unwilling participants. Ultimate victory is achieved if the game world becomes so toxic that everyone else but the griefers eventually stop coming, at which point the meta-opponents (ie the admins) have been 'beaten' and it's time to move onto some other game and wreck that. This was a bit easier to observe back in the days of dial-up MUDs when communities were smaller and you were likely to run into the same people on multiple platforms.
- DanBC 10y ago> That's the opposite of what I'm saying and I don't know how you drew that conclusion > > > they devote most of their effort to bullying weaker players They're not bullying weaker players. They're bullying much much stronger players.
- anigbrowl 10y agoDanBC, for example is playing fallacy bingo, misrepresenting what I said in order to 'discover' a contradiction and feel like s/he is the more logical person, at the expense of a little cognitive dissonance.
- dang 10y agoThis sort of perception is often in the eye of the beholder. Please be charitable and assume good faith, even when you don't feel like it. It makes a difference to the community.
- anigbrowl 10y agoThe first reply to my comment I did treat charitably (even though I thought it was a pointless derail), disagreeing but giving reasons for my point of view. In response to this, the other poster just restated his original objection rather than making any effort of his own, either to be charitable or to expand on his original argument. I agree that it's important to give someone the benefit of the doubt, but only a fool keeps doing it if there's no reciprocation. The presumption of good faith is after all the mechanism that trolls seek to exploit.
- dang 10y agoIf you think someone is trolling and breaking the site guidelines, you're welcome to alert us to that. You're not welcome to respond by breaking the site guidelines yourself. Everybody always feels that the other person started it and/or did it worse, so that argument can justify anything.
- xiaoma 10y agoYou're describing one of the four classic Bartle Types: https://repignite.com/2014/07/richard-bartle-player-types/ https://repignite.com/2014/07/richard-bartle-player-types/
- cannonpr 10y agoThere are generally quite a few forms of griefing, a popular one in Starcraft was to join a game were people were trying to pad their score 5 humans vs 1 easy computer opponent, then to betray the humans in a 1v4 game (an easy computer being irrelevant). There was a small asymmetric advantage, you were preparing for a hard game, they were preparing for an easy one, it was still a challenge though. What I am trying to point out here is that griefing is quite complicated and just points out that not everyone gets their enjoyment of a process by playing with the same rules as others.
- anigbrowl 10y agonot everyone gets their enjoyment of a process by playing with the same rules as others aka cheating because anonymity allows one to get away with it. If you want a game with different rules, find one. You don't get to invent new rules for yourself or your buddies and then point to them as justification when people call you out for behavior inconsistent with the rules they had agreed to. I mean, suppose I used my 1337 skillz to look up your home address and then came around one day and punched you in the nose? I doubt you'd be satisfied with the excuse that I get my enjoyment by playing with different rules from you about when physical violence is acceptable.
- cannonpr 10y agoWhile I do feel bringing up physical violence is a bit out of bounds in this conversation I can humour it. My point wasn't that I condone or condemn the behaviour, simply that different things motivate different people and if you wish to reduce a behaviour, a full understanding should come first. The article explore a bit of that but not enough.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI did choose it partly for the startle effect but also to capture the unexpected character of the griefing behavior when it impinges upon someone immersed in the game world. Maybe a better (if more absurd) example would be shooting fireworks at players at a sports game, so they were trying to duck bright-colored rockets rather than kicking or hitting or throwing a ball. It's easy to see how this could be quite entertaining, but if it were to become a regular thing it would get increasingly annoying to the people who wanted to watch a ball game of some sort, and doubly so to the people who had devoted themselves to playing at a professional level. The basic problem with griefing is that it depends on the unwillingness of some participants for its entertainment value to the other participants. The non-physicality of this violence - which is often merely replaced by imaginary violence - doesn't make it OK. It's still a violation insofar as it circumvents the agreed-upon rules of the game environment.
- markbnj 10y agoLeeerooooy Jenkins! Seriously, this has been going on forever, and the number one rule of trolls (and griefers are just trolls, as the piece points out) is don't give them attention or the reaction they're looking for, and they go away.
- have_faith 10y agoBeen a long time since I heard Leeroy Jenkins. Not giving them attention doesn't work if they are racking up millions of views on YouTube. There is a demand for it so someone will supply it for some e-fame. Tragedy is a cornerstone of comedy but we're in a strange time where empathy rarely travels across ethernet cables and making fun of someone carries little social repercussions on the internet. Until social dynamics change online trolls and griefers will always be close by.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI'm tired of that rule being trotted out. that's like saying the best response to crime is to not let people steal your wallet or they'll keep doing it. Well, duh, obviously, but a) you don't give any guidance on how to deal with them when they're actively interfering with your and b) it's not like these interactions happen in a vacuum or lack a systematic dimension. 'Just ignore it' is not helpful advice. It's an elaborate way of saying 'I don't know what to do about this problem and that lack of ideas is making me uncomfortable so please stop talking about it.'
- DanBC 10y agoIt's absolutely the best advice for this kind of trolling though. They say themselves that most people (80%) don't respond. http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-01-04-meet-the-griefers-article http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-01-04-meet-the-griefe... ^^^> The thing is - just as the victims of prank TV shows mostly laugh things off once the setup has been exposed - the griefers maintain that most people simply find their online antics amusing. Obviously they pick the most extreme reactions for their videos, but the majority of people just laugh at the silliness on display. Far from being enraged, most gamers are good-humoured enough that they simply play along. ^^^> Spartan Jay backs this up: "I would say that around 80 per cent of people that play online games are troll-proof. I guess my videos give people an unfair assumption of what the gaming community is really like. Most people I come across on games are fairly chilled out people. Sometimes when making a video, it can take over an hour before I find someone that will get angry over my griefing." When you say > 'Just ignore it' is not helpful advice. Well, it is helpful advice for this kind of trolling.
- js8 10y agoI stopped playing Minecraft on a public server because of griefers. While this guy can rationalize his antisocial behavior as "people need to lighten up", it's not really appreciated by others, who often invest their mental concentration to the game. Maybe there should be some sort of general gaming account (say Steam could have that), like a credit score. People who troll others would be more likely paired up with other trolls, if they so much enjoy company of "lightened up" people.
- ReverseCold 10y agoThis exists. [1] [1]: http://www.mcbans.com/ http://www.mcbans.com/
- ktRolster 10y agoHis research details that 59.5 per cent of gamers have intentionally trolled That's actually higher than I expected.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- stcredzero 10y agoMy ethos: If you can't enforce against it, then you co-opt it. Macro-miners? Give them an API. Griefers? Why turn down people who are so motivated to create interesting content for your game? Betrayal griefing could be co-opted as a part of the game as the possession of certain players by "the enemy."
- buzzybee 10y agoThere are (roughly) four things that can be done about griefing, cheating, and other toxic behaviors: 1. Design a game where toxicity is naturally mitigated. 2. Create limited spaces where people mutually agree on a code of conduct. 3. Conduct yourself virtuously within your space, to the best of your ability. 4. When someone breaks the code of your space, quietly exile them to the desert. Ideally everything is possible with point 1 alone, but at scale you inevitably encounter more and more persistent and skilled adversaries. Point 2 helps reduce the scale factor. Point 3 controls atmosphere - if you allow yourself to fly off the handle then you degrade the space. Point 4 is the last resort; you want conduct to proceed along a planned trajectory, but they consistently disrupt it. So the best you can do is remove them quickly and quietly before things explode, because nobody can be counted on to follow point 3 all the time and once it explodes the next hour or more will be spent discoursing over vigilantism and victimization and rights and freedoms instead of whatever you had planned. The alternative - allow anything to happen and "let people suck it up" - basically encourages Lord of the Flies in microcosm, which is very, very bad for a game. Somehow Twitter has managed to survive with it, though!
- DanBC 10y agoYou can't use the CJ phrase - it autokills your comments.
- dang 10y agoWe unkilled that comment and detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13251962 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13251962 and marked it off-topic.
- anigbrowl 10y agoAdding jargon and concern trolling isn't helping your argument.
- nitrogen 10y agoThis whole conversation seems a bit odd, like it's straying just slightly outside HN norms. Have the comments been edited? Or am I missing some self-referential griefer irony in this thread?
- anigbrowl 10y agoI don't think so. I do get shirty when I think someone is being willfully obtuse.
- DanBC 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13251935 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13251935 Have a look at that comment. Now log out and try to find it. Your comment got killed because you used a phrase. I've told you what that was, and that your comment got killed. I am unable to use the exact phrase because (obviously) doing so would kill my comment. > willfully obtuse. Yes, it's fucking infuriating even when it's not wilful.
- __david__ 10y agoBTW, after reading all these comments a day later it's my personal opinion that angribrowl is "griefing" the comment section here as some sort of performance art piece. It's the only "charitable" reading of their behavior.