You're begging the question of whether the FCC should or shouldn't have the same regulatory power over ISPs that it does over traditional common carriers. You'

You're begging the question of whether the FCC should or shouldn't have the same regulatory power over ISPs that it does over traditional common carriers. You're also begging the question of whether treating ISPs as common carriers grants the FCC power to "regulate the internet". Those are each highly debatable positions that you're assuming as truth. I'm not going to question your motives, but suffice it to say your argument is hardly convincing for making these assumptions.