4 ms·
>> compare the current "game" to what was originally promised That's a real issue with crowdfunding. More often than not, the devs truly have no idea what the
by sandworm101 10y ago
>> compare the current "game" to what was originally promised
That's a real issue with crowdfunding. More often than not, the devs truly have no idea what the final game will look like. Much of the early funding goes into what are essentially extended market research projects. Alphas are released, feedback taken, and changes made. Everyone expects that devs have some final version of "done" in their heads, but the truth is that such pictures constantly change in response to user/market feedback.
There are only a handful of indi games that ever developed towards a finite picture (Prison Architect). Most bounce around trying to please all the fans until some financial tipping point causes them to slap "1.0" on the latest build and push it out the door (KSP). That crowdfunding and traditional funding result in very different game development should be no surprise to anyone. StarCitizen will release when they need to release. Until then the cycle of feedback and iteration will continue.
- eterm 10y agoKSP was steam early access rather than crowdfunded per se, and was one of the early successes of steam's "early access", the funding made it into a very complete game and had regular updates and progress throughout the early access stages and didn't re-invent itself.
- sandworm101 10y agoIt wasn't only on steam. They also sold through their own store. I certainly didn't buy through steam. Whether the game is complete or not depends on when you got in on the process. What it does have is the layered and rather disconnected set of features that are typical of game development in response to market feedback rather than cohesive vision. It's a good game, but does show the telltales.
- izacus 10y agoWhat about Divinity: Original Sin, Pillars of Eternity and quite a few other crowdfunded games that were released and are good?
- sandworm101 10y agoI wasnt talking about good or bad. Thats a different issue than the process of their development. SC might or might not be good. Either way, its development follows a known pattern and the lack of set goals is part of that pattern.
- nightski 10y agoExcept you equated that pattern with crowdfunding which is rather untrue. Several examples were provided of successful games which delivered exactly what they set out to do more or less.