4 ms·
> Netgear stopped doing it. Netgear issued patches for the devices. Most people never update their server firmware, and we're talking about over 700,000 device
by DanBC 10y ago
> Netgear stopped doing it.
Netgear issued patches for the devices. Most people never update their server firmware, and we're talking about over 700,000 devices. The university still gets considerable traffic.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NTP_server_misuse_and_abuse#NETGEAR_and_the_University_of_Wisconsin.E2.80.93Madison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NTP_server_misuse_and_abuse#NE...
- agumonkey 10y agoCan't the university throttle non local connections ? (netgear could have provided the hardware ;)
- zamfi 10y agoNot necessary -- fortunately these routers all used source port 23457 for their NTP packets, making them trivially easy to block. I do recommend reading the incident report posted above if you have an interest in network operations, it's quite interesting!
- feld 10y agoYou still have to receive the traffic to block it.
- niij 10y agoIt is a public NTP server. Throttling public defeats the point.
- late2part 10y agoNot really. If an NTP client gets 1/10th of the updates that it wants, it will still keep reasonably good time.
- nickysielicki 10y agoKeeping a table of clients and their last-updated time is probably more expensive than just sending them a response.
- dom0 10y agoRandomly dropping a percentage of requests is stateless.
- foepys 10y agoBut what happens if you are the client whose requests are dropped all the time because you are unlucky?
- tedunangst 10y agoThen I guess you'll have to use somebody else's free server.
- zymhan 10y agoIs the NTP synchronization done with only a single packet? Because otherwise you'll be interrupting connections constantly.
- dogma1138 10y agoThrottling won't do much good; their WAN interfaces will still eat the traffic, I don't think it's as much of an issue that the NTP servers were melting it's more that their entire network was. For what you want to have any effect they'll have to sinkhole/throttle the traffic upstream before it ever reaches them and as a university they are effectively an ISP so that might not even be really possible.
- kalleboo 10y ago> The university still gets considerable traffic It'd be interested in seeing if there's been any update since 2003. E.g., is it really "considerable traffic" by 2016 standards? The original flood in 2003 was 150 MBps - I don't think I'd notice if I got a flood of 150 MBps on my home connection. How many of those devices are still around 13 years later?