3 ms·
It's a nonsensical idea. Imagine you are a soul, in limbo, somewhere outside the universe and elsewhere in another part of reality the universe is progressing
by jodrellblank 10y ago
It's a nonsensical idea.
Imagine you are a soul, in limbo, somewhere outside the universe and elsewhere in another part of reality the universe is progressing through its motions as time goes on. You are an other-reality-style being, yet somehow still allocated as "going to be a homosapiens on Milky Way\Sol\Earth", and your birth will be random during the era of homo sapiens.
Now you can argue about the likliehood of where this random birth happens.
On the other hand, take away the other place, and the souls, and the spooky assignment of types, and just look at the universe as a thing of matter and energy. Some configuration of matter was born to your parents, from their DNA. It is intimately connected to its surroundings by a continual stream of light, heat, air pressure, physical pressure; over millions of seconds it learns. It learns the patterns of air pressure that correspond to other people talking to it, and it learns what things it can and can't push by trying, and what other people talk about.
And it says "isn't it unlikely that I was born here and now, instead of some other time?"
And the question makes no sense. _What_ could have been born somewhere else? or somewhen else? Without its parents DNA, without its particular twenty continuous years of sensory input that it learned from, it would not be itself.
Some other matter, born to other parents, with other DNA, and other childhood experiences, and other knowledge patterns. It would be someone else. Entirely someone else. And ... that happens, we call it "other people".
If you don't believe in a soul, or something like it, what does it mean for you to possibly "be born somewhen else"?
- grkvlt 10y agoThe question is, what is the probability that a person picked at random from the human population, would be born during a technological era. We can work this out. Then, what is the probability that the part of the technological era they were born in was the first 100 years. This is easier to work out, it's 100/L_years(technological_era) but, unfortunately that's also the probability they are born in the second 100 years of a technological era of the same length, the third 100, the last 100 etc. so I don't think it gives us any predictive power?
- jodrellblank 10y agoNo, the question asked by the parent poster is "what is the probability that I would be born at this time in a long time frame". Which is what I was answering. You can't pick a human at random including from the future, unless you're outside the system somehow.
- grkvlt 10y agoThat just leads you down the road of discarding probabilities. Since something either happens or doesn't happen, the probability is either 100% for the things that will happen or 0% for those that do not. This is not a helpful position to take, although it is technically correct, in some not very useful sense. Humans are good at dealing in counterfactuals. 'What would have happened if I hadn't missed the bus?' is a useful question to ask, even if you did miss the bus. What would I be like if I hadn't gone to university/had taken that job/never killed my parents? Obviously the 'I' in those questions cannot be you, exactly, since you did or didn't do those things. But it's still a useful concept or thought experiment, and can give us valuable insights. The commenter is using 'I' in that counterfactual sense. And certainly, I understood what they meant by it, so they were successful in communicating (at least, to me) which is what matters with language.