6 ms·
All Hollowed Out the lonely poverty of America’s white working class
- calibraxis 10y ago"an extreme individualism has stepped in as the alternative—a go-it-alone perspective narrowly focused on getting an education and becoming successful on one’s own merit." It's ironic. Corporations are anything but individualist. They're collectives. Almost always top-down authoritarian structures that resemble fascism closer than most fascist governments. And full of bureaucracies that have nothing to do with making products, like marketing & finance depts. And in this article, "education" is a euphemism synonymous with college. Not talking about self-learning. Some administration that gives people certificates.
- vixen99 10y ago"resemble fascism closer than most fascist governments". Except of course that (1) the corporation only survives ultimately by selling a product or service that someone of their own free will, wishes to purchase; i.e., it is of more value to them than their cash. (2) local conditions excepted (no other job available), people are not forced to work in these organizations. Making products is all very well but if your potential customer doesn't know about it and/or its production is not financed properly, the activity is a waste of time.
- hyperdunc 10y ago"own free will" Well that's had highly debatable. Consider the amount of resources corporations spend trying to convince people what their will should be.
- dredmorbius 10y agoStandard Oil. Southern Improvement Corporation. British East India Company. Opium Wars. American Telephone and Telegraph. International Business Machines, German operations, 1930s & 1940s. Monsanto. Coca Cola. Tobacco. Detroit, the Big Three, and the safety and efficiency wars. Microsoft and the DoJ. Microsoft vs. DR DOS. Microsoft vs. Novell. Microsoft vs. Lotus. Microsoft vs. Netscape. Microsoft vs. Linux. Apple, Intel, Google, Cisco, and the anti-poaching cabal. Edward Bernays. Dole Fruit Company. The Pinkertons. United Steel strikebusting. The Triangle Shirtwaist Fire. I'd strongly recommend boning up on your history.
- internaut 10y ago> "education" is a euphemism synonymous with college Peter Thiel has described at length this kind of error https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLJIpBexKhQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLJIpBexKhQ It has always impressed me how doctrinal higher education as a terminal goal has become for the middle class. I personally believe it is utterly worthless for 9/10 of the people going to college right now. The students would be better off doing almost anything else.
- newdayrising 10y agoUntil you need to get a job and a bachelor's degree is required simply as a method to exclude candidates.
- internaut 10y agoRight. Even then most corporations think a BA is a shitty filter, before much longer they'll decide to educate bright 16 year olds on their own terms and selection process. Certainly that is what I'd do if I wanted to increase loyalty and employee retention.
- dang 10y agoWe've asked you before to stop using HN primarily for political arguments and ideological rhetoric. Doing so is an abuse of this site. You not only didn't stop, but continued to do nothing else; therefore we've banned this account. If you don't want it to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com with reason to believe that you'll use HN as intended. For those who are wondering, HN is intended for gratification of intellectual curiosity (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). Intellectual curiosity is far removed from political battle, and much weaker a force, so it needs protecting. Occasional political comments aren't a problem, so long as they're civil, but using HN primarily for politics is not ok. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13247955 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13247955 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- OliverJones 10y agoInteresting. Useful cross-references: Thomas Franks, book, Listen, Liberal. http://www.worldcat.org/title/listen-liberal-or-what-ever-happened-to-the-party-of-the-people/oclc/908628802 http://www.worldcat.org/title/listen-liberal-or-what-ever-ha... Franks makes the point that the USA is the only developed nation in the world where the major leftward-leaning political party does not appeal to working people, but rather to elites. A Bloomberg piece on how Larry Summers, president of Harvard, economic bigshot in Obama 44's first term, blasted Trump's move to keep some United Technologies (Carrier) mfg jobs in Indiana instead of moving them to a maquiladora. He blasted Trump on the grounds that politicians have no business trying to influence keeping jobs in their districts. That's an astonishing position. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-12-02/summers-slams-trump-s-carrier-move-as-threat-to-u-s-capitalism https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-12-02/summers-s... Max Weber, book, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protestant_Ethic_and_the_Spirit_of_Capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protestant_Ethic_and_the_S... This three-generation-old work digs in to the moral roots of lonely striving.
- rubberstamp 10y agoPeople like Larry Summers won't change their position unless their jobs get exported out of the country. Then they will sing a different song.
- maxxxxx 10y agoBefore jobs like his will be exported there will be legal action against that. The "free market" is only for the little guy.
- sjg007 10y agoYep.. faculty have unions.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoNot at private universities they don't.
- dwc 10y agoThis article agrees with other articles and books I've been reading on the topic. One interesting and troubling aside: This is focused on the working class and so doesn't talk very much about college educated people. But it does mention education, and still holds it up as a way forward. Well, that's also being hollowed out. There's a large and growing number of college graduates who cannot find a decent job and who amass large amounts of student debt. They did everything they were supposed to, but the jobs aren't there. Or the jobs are not what they used to be (see adjuncts v. tenure in academia, for instance). Or after all that schooling and debt, you have to "pay to play" by taking long term unpaid internships in expensive cities, which only the affluent can afford. This is bad on its own for people who would normally go to college and get white collar jobs, but it also destroys upward mobility for the working class. It's not just about unions and manufacturing any more. Hollowing out the middle class has become structural.
- jwhitlark 10y ago> They did everything they were supposed to... I think That sentiment is a big part of the problem right there. College isn't a checkbox, it's a tool to increase the value you can provide to others and yourself. Any credential is, at its core, just a proxy for expected value. If you give higher regard to the credential than the expected value, you're likely to have a bad time.
- dwc 10y agoWhile your statement is true, it doesn't explain nearly all of the problems. The shift from tenured to adjunct positions in academia doesn't have anything to do with the quality of applicants. The shift in tech from salaried employees to contractors (offshored or not) has nothing to do with the pool of qualified applicants. Lower pay for positions that create the same value are not the fault of the worker. When these sorts of issues become structural there are far fewer options for individuals to pursue. Whatever path they choose, their chances of success is less.
- throw2016 10y agoThe country has become a simulation of democracy. It principally exists for corporates and to further their interests, within the US and outside. Lobbying, regulatory capture, bankers, bailouts, a brazenly corrupt financial system, foreign policy warmongering, the security state, surveillance have been out of control for years now and show a state completely divorced from its citizens interests. Yet there is hardly a peep because there is no civic society. Structurally it seems the hatred between the various groups that form our society is so visceral and deep that a credible pushback is a near impossibility. Without any pushback what does one imagine happens? Entire sections of society have been thrown under the bus with hand waving and manufactured economic ideology. This is not how democracy works.