3 ms·
The decision last month was that the FCC did not have authority from Congress to regulate internet traffic. So now the FCC is attempting to reclassify cable pr
by btilly 17y ago
The decision last month was that the FCC did not have authority from Congress to regulate internet traffic. So now the FCC is attempting to reclassify cable providers in the same bucket as telephone providers. If courts accept this then the FCC has a very clear grant of authority from Congress to regulate as they wish.
The open question is whether the courts will accept this reclassification. This question will likely take several years to wind its way through the courts, but no matter how it turns out it will be a huge headache for the cable providers.
The fundamental issue here is whether net neutrality can be imposed on the cable providers. The standard meme is that net neutrality is a basic right. I am one of the few people who actually don't want net neutrality. Not because I trust ISPs to behave in a reasonable fashion, but because I think that the only real solution to bot nets is to make ISPs liable for the traffic that they let onto the Internet, and any such rule would be incompatible with net neutrality.
- swombat 17y agoBot nets are a small but annoying problem for a small percentage of people in the world. A pay-as-you-go, "we'll charge you extra for downloading 1MB from youtube rather than some other site" internet such as the one ISPs would like to aim towards would be a huge problem for everyone. Have a sense of proportions...
- btilly 17y agoSmall but annoying? Try saying that to someone who runs a website that has been forced to pay extortion fees as the price of staying up. And truth be told, if the public had any idea how often bot nets are responsible for their computers running slowly and their personal financial details getting stolen, there would be a lot of justified outrage about that as well. Just because people aren't aware of how big a problem it is doesn't mean that it isn't a big problem.