3 ms·
The agency gets to classify new technology in different buckets. They put the ISPs in the data provider bucket. So the providers started screwing people over d
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
The agency gets to classify new technology in different buckets. They put the ISPs in the data provider bucket.
So the providers started screwing people over depending on what kind of bits they wanted to get over the net -- the beginning of some god-awful 74-thousand tiered pricing structure.
Lots of fuss about that. FCC tries to step in. Court says nope, in that bucket you don't have the authority to act.
So the FCC puts them in new bucket. Huge part of the economy now regulated and nobody had to elect anybody, there was no bill, no debate, no nothing (And I support this, but damn it's a freaking Faustian bargain if I ever saw one)
- francoisdevlin 17y agoEh, it's not as bad as you think. We (congress) gave the FCC the authority to do this. Granted, we didn't quite understand the implications when we did, but it is still a democratic process.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoLOL. Yes, I understand how the regulatory process works. Apologies if I seemed to mislead anyone. There is nothing unconstitutional going on. But that doesn't take away from the fact that the regulatory agencies have immense power in our society -- granted to them by Congress. For instance, the DEA can classify new drugs as dangerous, including setting what the jail time will be for possession -- and Congress has virtually no role[1]. Used to be it took an entire constitutional amendment to outlaw alcohol, but now a commission does the same work and there's little publicity. [1] Ok, so they have "oversight", but as somebody who has seen oversight behind the scenes, and watched a lot of it on C-SPAN, color me unimpressed. EDIT: Another good one is the EPA classifying CO2 -- the air we breathe -- as being under it's regulatory guidance. Now they made provision so that it only covers large producers of CO2, but that was their decision as an agency. There was no public debate or vote in Congress. Just a bunch of guys sitting around a conference table. Once again, I support the outcome in this case. I'm not trying to argue that it's a bad outcome. Just not crazy about the way we got here, or the implications for broadband 20 years from now.
- francoisdevlin 17y agoAh, I see what you're getting at now. I'll now take the ostrich approach (stick your head in the ground & pretend it's okay) when it comes to dealing with specific government agencies. I don't want to know the details.
- gte910h 17y agoPart of their oversight is the court system. Legislative branch sets out what should happen (but misses details) Executive branch fills in the details via implementation Judicial branch tells them when they screwed up the details or the legislative branch did something that conflicts with higher law.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThis thread is turning into a civics lesson. Yes, you are correct. "Oversight" committees are set up by Congress to manage the authority they were given. These are -- well, start watching some if you'd like to know what they are. And don't let the Congressmen tell you their staff is on top of it. Managing Congressional staff is something the various agencies have learned a long, long time ago. The agency itself is a part of the executive branch. So theoretically they report to the president. In practice, however, the government is a huge thing. It is highly unusual to be within 3 people of reporting to the executive. The president makes political appointments, and the top people at each agency are those who manage those guys. Usually contractors are brought in to create a lot of presentations and such so that staff can show to the political hack how great the agency is. Over time agencies get very, very good at managing the hacks and resisting change. After all, the agency is full of people there for life. These guys are just passing through. It's not unusual for the president to bring in activists or ex-corporate types as their political hacks. After all, these guys are contributors and they are interested and qualified (but also have many hidden agendas) The courts technically oversee whether or not the agencies act in a constitutional manner -- the idea being that although Congress can delegate huge swaths of its power to agencies, it can't delegate something it never had. Appellate courts step in when federal agencies overstep, but historically in an ad-hoc manner. http://www.jstor.org/pss/2647783 http://www.jstor.org/pss/2647783 The worst abuses with the most political imapct are caught. Lots of little guys get trampled.