2 ms·
Completely fails to address how anything "blockchain" consumes tons of resources and has horrific latency.
by TylerE 10y ago
Completely fails to address how anything "blockchain" consumes tons of resources and has horrific latency.
- Animats 10y agoBlockchains aren't expensive unless they're anonymous. If they're anonymous, you need something like "mining" as a proxy for reputation. If the players in a blockchain are a dozen known mutually mistrustful banks, that's not a problem. It takes a majority of the players, acting together, to make a change. Banks are interested in this sort of thing because they need clearing intermediaries, and those intermediaries are expensive organizations to operate. The parent article, though, is a solution looking for a problem.
- TD-Linux 10y agoAnonymity and decentralization are two different things, you can have one and not the other. For example, Bitcoin and most other cryptocurrencies has decentralization (mining) but only weak anonymity (all transactions are public). The decentralization is most of the cost, but adding anonymity (like zcash) adds even more cost with larger transactions.
- yarrel 10y agoCompletely fails to demonstrate the relevance of this as a critique here. (Proof of Stake, Sharding, and depending on your use case zero-confirmation transactions or shorter block times solve the problems you identify here.)
- TylerE 10y agoNone of those have been proven at anything resembling scale. Because some altcoin with 15 users does it doesn't mean it _works_.