My claim is that the word "conscious" must be clearly defined before you make any claims about whether or not any entity is conscious. Same goes for the word "

My claim is that the word "conscious" must be clearly defined before you make any claims about whether or not any entity is conscious. Same goes for the word "dream." I must say I find it bizarre that observing an biological entity twitch during a state of decreased activity causes people to speculate that some sort of magic is happening. Or even that they need these concepts that they are unwilling to define to explain it.