4 ms·
I still have a 500 rupee somewhere; most likely packed in a box in my parents' basement. Did no one consider the consequences of this move? Surely there were p
by djsumdog 10y ago
I still have a 500 rupee somewhere; most likely packed in a box in my parents' basement.
Did no one consider the consequences of this move? Surely there were people in government that testified to the fact that over 80% of the currency in circulation were these larger bills?
Either this was intentional to move to the country to electronic payments or some elected people didn't listen to anybody, did no analysis and were so clueless they didn't realize this would happen?!
If their elected officials really cared about the people as much as they cared about stopping corruption, they should have figured out some type of gradual roll-out policy. Or they could have simply allowed 500/1000 notes but refused to print any more and ordered banks to send all of those notes to their mint. They could then slowly replace the notes over a year and eventually, declare 500/1000 not legal tender after a year, rather than trying to do this all at once.
- vidarh 10y agoThe point of doing it all at once was to make it harder for those with untaxed cash to have time to find a workarounds. A longer window would defeat the stated goal entirely. > Did no one consider the consequences of this move? Surely there were people in government that testified to the fact that over 80% of the currency in circulation were these larger bills? The supposed large hoards of untaxed cash in these denominations would be the very argument for this move. It's quite possible they've messed up the implementation or got the distribution of these notes wrong, but the stated argument for doing this would be entirely moot if they didnt make up a large portion of the currency in circulation.
- denzil_correa 10y ago> The point of doing it all at once was to make it harder for those with untaxed cash to have time to find a workarounds. A longer window would defeat the stated goal entirely. Lesser than 10% (most aggressive estimate) of the unaccounted income lies in cash. As such, the entire exercise has higher costs than benefits. The idea AND the implement both have no sound reason.
- whitenoice 10y agoCould you provide source to how you came about with that estimate?
- aianus 10y agoNot OP but the Indian Central Bank estimates there are ~$239 billion in outstanding currency [0], and the national wealth of India is estimated at $3 trillion [1]. Rich people have a much lower cash:wealth ratio than poor or middle class people so I highly doubt many rich people, no matter how corrupt, are losing more than 10% of their wealth with this move. [0] https://rbi.org.in/Scripts/BS_PressReleaseDisplay.aspx?prid=38857 https://rbi.org.in/Scripts/BS_PressReleaseDisplay.aspx?prid=... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_wealth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_wealth
- denzil_correa 10y agoTax raids and White paper on Black Money by Min. of Finance.
- wav-part 10y agohttp://www.ndtv.com/india-news/who-knew-pm-narendra-modis-black-money-move-kept-a-closely-guarded-secret-1635822 http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/who-knew-pm-narendra-modis-bl... > Prime Minister Narendra Modi handpicked a trusted bureaucrat, little known outside India's financial circles, to spearhead a radical move to abolish 86 percent of the country's cash overnight and take aim at the huge shadow economy. > Hasmukh Adhia, the bureaucrat, and five others privy to the plan were sworn to utmost secrecy, say sources with knowledge of the matter. They were supported by a young team of researchers working in two rooms at Prime Minister Modi's residence, as he plotted his boldest reform since coming to power in 2014. > It was made up of young experts in data and financial analysis; some ran Prime Minister Modi's social media accounts and a smartphone app that he used to solicit public feedback.
- kbenson 10y ago> > It was made up of young experts in data and financial analysis; some ran Prime Minister Modi's social media accounts and a smartphone app that he used to solicit public feedback. So, either they had experts in data and financial analysis running social media accounts and (creating?) a smartphone app he used to get feedback, or at least some of these "experts" had their area of expertise somewhere other than data and financial analysis. I know what I think is more likely...
- wav-part 10y agoWhat troubles me more is, How did they come to ban-notes as conclusion considering the economy is mostly underground/decentrealized (ie they dont/cant have the data). (Observation) India is highly decentralized/resilient. In India, Govt is just a thing. People dont pay much mind to it. They minimize interaction with Govt and bear it when they have to. But this time I think Govt overdid it.
- justin66 10y ago> If their elected officials really cared about the people as much as they cared about stopping corruption All my middle-class Indian friends applaud the move. More significantly, Modi appears to still be quite popular in India. It seems people resent the black money more than they resent the inconvenience this change represents. YMMV.
- sfifs 10y agoOne way to think about this is the objective is to win a bunch of upcoming state elections and retain power in the next national elections. NO ONE has ever before in Indian politics made such a bold move. The Modi government made this move a couple of months before elections in the biggest states and suddenly the gossip amongst common folks in the street is all about the attempts by the corrupt rich to desperately get rid of old banknotes, how bankers are being arrested etc. etc. and not about the political stance of the party which some castes and the minority community have historically found alienating. From what I observe the corrupt in a soup appears to give most common folk much more satisfaction from schadenfreude than the inconvenience they are bearing
- akbar501 10y agoSteve Forbes wrote about the lack of planning and impact on ordinary citizens: http://www.forbes.com/sites/steveforbes/2016/12/22/what-india-has-done-to-its-money-is-sickening-and-immoral/#5b21a6b21148 http://www.forbes.com/sites/steveforbes/2016/12/22/what-indi...