3 ms·
> Based on the DNA evidence, it is an absolute fact that his friend Yancy raped and robbed the woman. That is not how facts work. The DNA evidence shows that t
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> Based on the DNA evidence, it is an absolute fact that his friend Yancy raped and robbed the woman.
That is not how facts work. The DNA evidence shows that the DNA was there. It doesn't create a fact out of something else.
It could be that the woman consented to sex with one or both of the men and fabricated the story to explain it to her boyfriend. It could be that McKinny and the woman's boyfriend were gay and the accusation was the woman's revenge after catching her boyfriend in bed with a man. We still don't know these things.
- dogma1138 10y agoThis evidence alone combined with his own admission of the crime is not sufficient for exoneration. He gave an alibi to someone that was involved in the crime as far DNA goes; he admitted to the crime (although it could have been the case that he done so only to admit guilt as there is no parole without admission of guilt) and asked for forgiveness. I don't know if there is other considerable evidence to him being present during the burglary and the rape such as fingerprints but another likely option was that there were 3 individuals involved in the burglary 2 of them raped the victim and the 3rd haven't. In my opinion if you commit a crime with with partners and one of the partners assaults, rapes, or kills some one you are just as guilty as they are for not preventing them in most case; the law in most places agrees with this. Robbing a house with 1-2 other people and then standing by while they rape some one is nearly as bad as raping someone yourself.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoHave you responded to the wrong post? None of that has anything to do with what the DNA proves.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe DNA on it's own proves nothing; it's just a piece of evidence this isn't how a legal system works.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> The DNA on it's own proves nothing That was my point.
- tveita 10y agoIf any of this was the case they should probably have tried stating it as part the defense to counter the evidence against them. I think it's unnecessary for us to invent crazy hypothetical scenarios above and beyond what the accused themselves are claiming just to avoid confronting the possibility that a rape charge might be real and not she totally wanted it man. That said, even disregarding the question of guilt it does sound like a shitty way to treat released prisoners, and I'm sure recidivism could be reduced by a lot if you gave them a runway and more help reintegrating.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> I think it's unnecessary for us to invent crazy hypothetical scenarios above and beyond what the accused themselves are claiming just to avoid confronting the possibility that a rape charge might be real and not she totally wanted it man. A woman making a false rape claim to avoid admitting that she cheated is a "crazy hypothetical scenario"? It's a thing that actually happens on a recurring basis. It's probably the leading cause of false rape claims. I am not arguing that these people are innocent. They probably did it. But they didn't certainly do it. DNA can't fix that because the pieces we don't know aren't the pieces that DNA tells us.