4 ms·
Check Fig. 4 and the discussion: "Column 1 in Fig. 4 in the first block of columns (corresponding to wages) shows that IQ predicts wages, but the predictive po
by mcguire 10y ago
Check Fig. 4 and the discussion:
"Column 1 in Fig. 4 in the first block of
columns (corresponding to wages) shows that IQ predicts
wages, but the predictive power is small (around 1% [Adj. R squared of 0.02 in Fig. 4). Column
2 in Fig. 4 shows that self-esteem, locus of control, antisocial
behavior, and neuroticism, taken together, are more important
determinants of wages [R sq. Of .05]. Both IQ and personality remain as
important predictors in wage equations when both are included
in a regression (column 3 in Fig. 4). The fourth column in Fig. 4
shows that achievement has more predictive power than IQ and
personality alone. When IQ and personality are also included in
a regression (column 5 in Fig. 4), achievement test scores remain an important predictor of wages, and IQ and personality
also remain important predictors of wages. After controlling for
scores on achievement tests, IQ loses around 60% of its predictive power. When grades are included, instead of achievement tests, the effect of IQ becomes negligible. A similar pattern
arises across the other outcomes studied."
The achievement measure is from a test (of learned facts and skills?) at age 10 (IIUC).
Further, the paper seems to go to some effort to decompose the raw data into IQ, grades. See table 2. The correlation between iq and personality is fairly weak.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoThe problem is that achievement tests and grades are a measure of IQ. Imagine I have a direct relationship, y = g. Now I measure compute a noisy data set, (x,y) with x = g + noise. Depending on the size of the noise I'll discover that y is correlated with g with some R^2. My regression coefficient will come out to be approximately y = 1x. Now imagine I made a new noisy data set, (x1, x2, x3, y). Here x1 = g + noise, x2 = g + noise, x3 = g + noise. Here x1 might be IQ, x2 might be SAT or other such g-loaded test, x3 grades, etc. My new regression coefficients are y = (1/3)x1 + (1/3)x2 + (1/3)x3. Suddenly x1 has lost 2/3 of it's predictive power! The problem is that my measurements are correlated, that's all. And as you note, table 2 shows a pretty solid correlation between IQ, personality, achievement and grades. If you actually want to draw the conclusion that the article is trying to draw, you need to decouple IQ from the other measurements.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoIn order for them to be directly related as you suggest, all high-iq participants need to memorize lots of facts and learn lots of skills and no low-iq participants can do similarly. It seems that, by citing them as separate factors, the authors are saying this is not true for the population they considered.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoTable 2 shows it is true.
- mcguire 10y agoTable 2 shows the pairwise correlations. The highest is between iq and achievement: 0.4-0.7 on different datasets. The correlation between iq and grades is between 0.1 and 0.5. That's strong, but not 1.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoMy critique doesn't require a correlation of 1, I just used that as a simple example where I could work out the math in my head.