7 ms·
Getting rich, at least under our current system, has a lot more to do with luck (mainly being in the right place at the right time) than it does with being smar
by lisper 10y ago
Getting rich, at least under our current system, has a lot more to do with luck (mainly being in the right place at the right time) than it does with being smart or even working hard. The reason perseverance (which is related to working hard, but is not quite the same thing) helps is that the more willing you are to keep playing the game without winning the more likely you are to eventually win.
(You can see this dynamic at work in the small here on HN. Getting a lot of upvotes has more to do with getting a pithy comment in early enough that it rises to the top where it gets noticed before the story falls off the front page and people stop paying attention. The wisest comment in the world won't get any love if it's submitted after the story drops off the home page. A similar dynamic also plays itself out on the New page. It's even more dramatic there because very few people ever look at the New page. And yet, the more participate, the more likely you are to hit an upvote jackpot.)
- NicoJuicy 10y agoGetting rich is doing instead of thinking. Smart people tend to overthink to much.
- christmaswoot 10y agoGetting rich is having instead of being. Dumb people underthink.
- beachstartup 10y agono, being rich is having. in order to get rich, you must do. many smart people overthink, constantly, and to a fault. it usually manifests in the form of 'what if something goes wrong???' and spirals from there. any rich person will tell you, things go wrong constantly, and at the worst possible time. the only important thing is your confidence in your ability to fix things when they break.
- Fnoord 10y ago> it usually manifests in the form of 'what if something goes wrong???' and spirals from there. That is because we compare to the successful rich only, not all those who tried to become rich and utterly failed. This is just masculine vs feminine thinking. Or VC versus slow growth. Or the way we nurture children in the West vs cats, or in Africa. Or quality vs quantity. You never hear about all the times people prayed to $diety and it didn't help. You never hear about all those people who went to Stanford and didn't graduate. You never hear about all those people who made a startup and failed. OK, you do (on the latter, here), but it takes courage, shame, and selfishness. PS: You might wanna use some capital letters at the start of a sentence.
- beachstartup 10y agoi swear all you trolls read from the same exact playbook. "nobody hears about the failures"? really? i hear about plenty of failures all around me. i see restaurants shutting down left and right. i see people having mental breakdowns, public freakouts, people drop out of school. marriages fall apart, houses get repossessed, stock markets crash, people go bankrupt, even commit suicide. startups failing and people not getting rich is honestly the least, most insignificant of all of life's failures. but so what? so just do nothing with your life? never try anything? grow up.
- Fnoord 10y ago> so just do nothing with your life? never try anything? That's not the point. The point is that many fail, the success / failure ratio is low. Period. No need to be judgmental past that. Or resort to namecalling. If you think someone is trolling. Don't reply. Ignore them. Heck, report them.
- lisper 10y agoNo, unfortunately it's not. I know this from first hand experience. I've been doing my whole life, but the most money I ever made (by a huge margin) came from a stroke of dumb luck.
- lisper 10y agoEDIT: That should have read, "I've been doing startups my whole life"
- throwaway190823 10y agoSounds a bit like, http://www.shenlanguage.org/lambdassociates/htdocs/blog/bipolar.htm http://www.shenlanguage.org/lambdassociates/htdocs/blog/bipo... I can add that academia is generally equally part of the same order. The game gets quite annoying after a while, since you realize one is basically doing the same x + delta thing and calling it the next great coming.
- ikeboy 10y agoI've noticed that a lot of successful people got there by doing things that, on the surface, don't seem to need a lot of brainpower. But, when you get to know them more, you find that they're smart. I think that very often, being smart leads someone to succeed but invisibly, so it's easy for others who don't know the whole story to attribute it to luck.
- lisper 10y agoBeing smart helps stack the deck in your favor, but it is neither necessary nor sufficient. Ben Carson and Steve Harvey are both rich, but I wouldn't consider either of them particularly smart.
- ikeboy 10y agoNeurosurgeons have higher than average IQ, and Carson is one of the best. He's smart. I don't know much about Harvey, but ironically I found this article http://www.inc.com/jeff-haden/steve-harvey-success-series-kick-your-fear-of-failure.html http://www.inc.com/jeff-haden/steve-harvey-success-series-ki... >Spend time with a person who is very successful in some field or pursuit; it doesn't matter what. After a few minutes you'll probably think, "Wait, this guy isn't any smarter than me." After a few more minutes you'll probably think, "Hey, I'm actually smarter than he is." Success doesn't require a high IQ or some special intangible quality that you don't have. Successful people only become "special" after they succeed; before they put in all that time and effort they were just like everyone else. Spend time with a few successful people and you will realize you are just as capable of achieving great things. I disagree with some of this, as above. There's some of each, some lucky and some skilled. But I think skill plays a bigger role in the variance of similarly situated people. Luck in the sense of where you're born, how privileged your family is, etc play a larger role than luck later in life, I think. I also consider brains a luck factor as well.
- lisper 10y ago> Neurosurgeons have higher than average IQ That's the conventional wisdom, but is it really true? Or do they just have above average mechanical skills? I followed Carson closely during the presidential campaign and I saw no evidence that he's particularly smart (and quite a bit of evidence to the contrary).
- whack 10y agoIt depends on what you mean by "rich". If your goal is to be a billionaire, then yes, luck plays a major role. But if you simply want to get to the 99th percentile of income/wealth, that can be achieved in a pretty replicable manner. Study hard in HS -> Go to a good college -> Work your ass off for a good GPA -> go do a MBA/JD/MD/CS degree at an elite university -> get a six figure job and work your ass off. Not much luck involved there. Interestingly, you don't need to have mensa-level IQ to achieve the above either. Hard work and grit is far more important, which is what the article is saying as well.
- lisper 10y agoThere cannot possibly be a reliable process to get you to the 99th percentile, because by definition 99% of people won't get there. Hard work will reliably get you to the 99th percentile only in a world where only 1% of people work hard.
- whack 10y ago> "Hard work will reliably get you to the 99th percentile only in a world where only 1% of people work hard." Yes, and that's exactly the world we live in today. Most people don't work hard enough in their teenage-years/20s to become high paying doctors/lawyers/bankers.
- lisper 10y agoDo you have any actual evidence to support that assertion, or are you just affirming the consequent? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirming_the_consequent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirming_the_consequent)
- whack 10y agoI'm making an assertion based on my own personal experiences, just like I'm assuming you're doing as well. I've yet to meet someone who studied/worked all the time during their high-school/college/career, and still failed to secure a six figure income.