4 ms·
The upside here is that these are the sorts of measures that will allow visa-free travel to continue. Ultimately, many countries that were once zero-risk consi
by Spooky23 10y ago
The upside here is that these are the sorts of measures that will allow visa-free travel to continue.
Ultimately, many countries that were once zero-risk considerations for entry are becoming riskier. The world is changing, people are migrating away from war in the middle east and other places and the US governments policy is to deny people deemed risky entry. Other countries require visas to deal with this sort of thing. US citizens of Pakistani origin need to jump through hoops to get an Indian visa, for example. That's far more intrusive and harmful.
It's intrusive, but why should your virtual identity be different than your physical identity?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- msravi 10y ago> US citizens of Pakistani origin need to jump through hoops to get an Indian visa, for example. That's far more intrusive and harmful. With good reason, after the 26/11 Mumbai attack, which had the extensive involvement of an US citizen of Pakistani origin[1]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Headley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Headley
- tehlike 10y agogood reason is very relative, i guess. You can find extremists in any nation/religion, and it doesn't make much sense to make life hard for _everyone else_.
- msravi 10y agoIn order to sort the bad apples you do need some sort of filter. You can do it either by (a) having sets of hierarchical filters with increasingly finer pores, or (b) with a single filter with the finest possible pores that everyone is put through. Ironically, having a coarse filter that sorts people based on nationality/religion as one of the first level filters actually makes life easier for everyone else. The other option is to profile everyone and pass these profiles through an extremely fine filter - which is what the SM profile information in the article seems to be targeted for. So, choose your poison. Do you want everyone to be intensively profiled at the cost of privacy, or do you want to be filtered using broad parameters such as religion and nationality?
- tehlike 10y agosounds to me like racial profiling. I am really curious how much this is helping in terms of false positives, and false negatives. I believe in data, and i am just curious about the numbers, so i could be convinced about its usefulness. As coming from somewhat chaotic part of the world to have some peaceful life, the hoops I had to jump through (visas, immigration, airport checks, constant secondary inspections etc), it really bothers me. Mind you, I am a white male with very good educational background in my own country, and in the US. Hard to imagine what it is like for some other people who may not be as lucky as I am. Either way, as much as I dislike US immigration and so on, I cannot complain. This country provides me the opportunities that I have been working for, and I am grateful.
- msravi 10y agoRight, the data. So the proper way to do this would be to set up a massive A/B test, with everyone entering the US to be randomly assigned to one of two groups - either you're put into the hierarchical filter and you're profiled based on broad first-level parameters, or you're put into the fine filter and you're forcibly opted in into intensive surveillance for the next couple of years or so. Then measure the false positives, hits, and misses and take a decision. Seems to me that this step is probably the first of several by the US immigration to get this data and justify the move away from broad profiling (which they've taken flak for), towards the need for more intense profiling (which they're also taking flak for).
- mattip 10y agoAssuming you were serious, a/b testing works only when you can determine the value of the outcome. How many of the millions of people who pass through immigration need to be rejected for reasons of national security?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- stonogo 10y agoGee, Spooky23, why should they be different?
- wyager 10y ago> The upside here is that these are the sorts of measures that will allow visa-free travel to continue. The only danger to visa-free travel is from governments. Visa-free travel is a thing that exists naturally and gets taken away. The only requirement for visa-free travel to continue is for governments to not become increasingly paranoid and authoritarian. > It's intrusive, but why should your virtual identity be different than your physical identity? Why should they be the same? I'm honestly kind of confused with this question. "Why shouldn't the government lock travelers in a room and torture them for information?" Because it's unpleasant and the costs outweigh the benefits. Additionally, it's trivial to fake a social media presence or deny having one. These Orwellian measures don't actually accomplish anything productive.
- Spooky23 10y ago> Why should they be the same? I'm honestly kind of confused with this question. "Why shouldn't the government lock travelers in a room and torture them for information?" That's a false equivalence. My question is: Why does your online activity deserve special protections that activity offline does not? If you get a DUI you'll be denied entry to Canada. Why is Orwellian to do the same on the basis of a video you post on Facebook showing you driving drunk?
- wheelerwj 10y agobecause people make videos and write stories that are fictional. should Robert Downey JR be denied entry because he destroyed new york while fighting aliens?
- UnoriginalGuy 10y ago> My question is: Why does your online activity deserve special protections that activity offline does not? You have it backwards. This is far more invasion than anything they ask for offline. Your social media profiles (particularly private ones) may contain private conversations you have with friends, colleagues, and love interests. To use an offline analogy, it is like the US government asking you to tape record private conversations you have with friends at home, and then give them the recordings to gain access to the US. Would you support the US Government asking people to tape record private conversations? Then why is it ok when it is on a technological platform? Why is voice more protected than text? Do you feel like people going to Disneyland should give up all privacy to do so?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- verelo 10y agoWell for one, there are things they cannot ask you. Ie sexual preference and religion, both things your social presence likely exposes. It's completely different, I just hope they never want my hacker news account, because they will see this comment and know I think the US has completely lost its sense of what is right and wrong.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y ago> It's intrusive, but why should your virtual identity be different than your physical identity? Said the person posting from an anonymous account. Why is this online identity not tied to your physical one? What is your name/street address/mother's maiden name/email addresses? I don't really want the answer, I just want to point out the hypocrisy. Plus there's no evidence that these measures make the US safer, least of all because a "bad guy" will be ready with fake clean accounts. It will only catch low level naughtiness and most of that will be false positives anyway (e.g. you made a joke ten years ago that is going to be misinterpreted on purpose). Ultimately this kind of behaviour at the US's borders only harms tourism/business. Why would I go to a US trade conference when I could go to China or Europe instead and get treated far better? Why would I start a business in the US when nobody wants to travel there? But Americans will just sit in their little bubble and continue to trade other people's privacy for minor and impossible to prove increases in security. America has become a snivelly coward of a country.
- Spooky23 10y agoIf I was asked for my HN handle, I'd respond truthfully. Lying to a Federal law official is a felony in the US and if not a crime a very bad idea everywhere else. There's a lot of outrage and knee-jerk outrage and down-voting, but nobody has meaningfully answered the question I posed. People who have committed lone-wolf terrorist attacks have voluntarily and publicly posted their intention to do so on social media. It's a thing. Why is that irrelevant to a customs official? If you try to enter Canada as a US Citizen with a 20 year old DUI conviction, you'll be barred for entry without a visa-like process. Why is that acceptable?
- PavlovsCat 10y agoSo you're basically saying someone who is in some kind of minority or has some kind of special hardship or toxic people or family in their life that make them prefer to stay anonymous, but who still want to mingle and make friends and speak their mind freely are just out of luck? This, and other things, is what it wouldy imply. Another thing it implies is that police are so shitty -- or their superiors so in cahoots with the entitities that do the murdering for that matter -- that they absolutely need to have the self-incriminating stuff someone might spout in public or they can't do their job. Have they given up on catching dangerous people who, uhm, might not do any of that, ever? If someone posts on Facebook that they're going to do a bombing, they might repeat it to the people they ask for directions there, so why fret about those of all people? Maybe, just maybe, because it's not about catching the worst criminals in the least intrusive way possible, but using those crimes as a stepping stones to get to the innocent? Dress it up however you want it, at the end of the day this is the bottom line for over a decade. If it was about catching mass murderers someone would have arrested people like Bush and Blair by now, so that's kind of a clue to anyone seriously interested in the subject matter :P