5 ms·
> Even given the inefficiencies of government, it's hard for me to imagine that the same amount of social spending could do more good from the hands of individu
by paulddraper 10y ago
> Even given the inefficiencies of government, it's hard for me to imagine that the same amount of social spending could do more good from the hands of individuals than collective agencies.
(1) Imagine harder.
Get personal experience or talk to someone with personal experience with WIC, food stamps, disability, medicare/medicaid, etc. and you'll find out how inefficient, wasteful, and abused these things are. And I don't just mean by a little bit. I mean by A LOT.
(2) I agree that collective agencies can be more effective than individuals.
But not the government kind that are (a) awfully inefficient and (b) exact their contributions by force. I donate a significant portion of my income voluntarily to organizations of my choice that do good in better ways than writing legally mandated entitlement checks.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jwatte 10y agoAll of the welfare budget together (of which some fraction might be waste or fraud) is only a small fraction of the governments budget. Corporations the size of governments are equally inefficient. Finally, one major way we could make government more effective is to institute a public, national id number and allow data sharing between between agencies. But we don't trust our own government enough to do that. (Many civilized countries do, and it works great for them)
- paulddraper 10y ago"great" is relative. Every other days some article rises to the top of HN about government surveillance.
- areyousure 10y agoThe person you responded to included "medicare/medicaid" in their list of government services. They each cost over half a trillion dollars per year.