5 ms·
First, when it comes to stories like this, libertarianism is basically irrelevant in the real world. To a first approximation, even in Silicon Valley, there are
by jerf 10y ago
First, when it comes to stories like this, libertarianism is basically irrelevant in the real world. To a first approximation, even in Silicon Valley, there aren't any. The Valley is far better known for its progressivism than its libertarianism now.
Second, I am unaware of any tenant of libertarianism that says it is somehow bad for people to band together into charity organizations, potentially the very same ones mentioned in the article, and for other people to give money to those organizations. Nothing about libertarianism requires altruistically-minded individuals to literally go out into the streets and start handing out dollar bills to individuals or something. Libertarianism is about not being coerced to join organizations, not about organizations existing.
- mindslight 10y agoLibertarianism is also generally aligned against the Keynesian puppeteering that has created this gilded overinvestment bubble and regressive income-dissipating treadmill. Furthermore, non-transmuted [0] libertarianism is fundamentally against the concentration of communication/power that has caused these parasitic nouveau-middlemen companies to even be a thing! These principles are slow-acting general concepts, and so they do not address the immediate problem. Obviously if someone is hungry, you feed them first and then figure out how to avoid them getting into that situation in the future. [0] Every political group starts off with valid critiques and seeking sanity, but the commercially useful parts are then overemphasized to support the status quo power structure. A true libertarian is inherently against large corporations (as there is no difference between a totalitarian government from an all-owning all-contracting corporation), even though they're easily tricked into condoning them.
- warkdarrior 10y ago> A true libertarian is inherently against large corporations Wouldn't that limit the freedom of the owners/shareholders to grow their corporation to whatever size they want? And who gets to decide how large is large? The government?
- wav-part 10y agoNo. It means small compititors band together to compete against the market leader.
- mindslight 10y agoFirstly, even without a concrete mechanism morals still exist. You're actually the one referencing the idea of an omnipotent government actor and needing to create an explicit constraint. But an underlying philosophy of libertarianism is actually to find mechanisms that don't involve centralized ("state") actors. For one example, if more individuals sought out Free software, the Googles of the world would have a less "scalable" audience.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wav-part 10y ago> (as there is no difference between a totalitarian government from an all-owning all-contracting corporation), even though they're easily tricked into condoning them. Law works because everyone concent and choose to follow it. If you have such single non-violent corporation then there is nothing stops from people to just walk away.
- mindslight 10y agoIf you reverse your sentences, you actually address your own point - > If you have such single non-violent corporation then there is nothing stops from people to just walk away. > Law works because everyone concent and choose to follow it ... with the implication that people could choose to walk away from specific laws, which they can but just require a sizable group to do so. Coming at it from the other direction, a non-violent corporation can still be coercive if it say owns all of the land and you must rent for a place to exist, or even if you own your land it owns all the roads you must sign a contract to travel. Would you feel better by just viewing USG as a corporation with a contract that you continue to consent to by not having left? The straightforward response is that a contract to use a road should be scope-constrained to the topic of road usage, and not say also preclude you from using drugs on your own property. But that's no longer as simple and universal as a belief in unlimited contracts.
- wav-part 10y ago> Would you feel better by just viewing USG as a corporation with a contract that you continue to consent to by not having left? Yes I agree. So lets assume we have someone who has monopoly on land (like USG) and who is non-violent (unlike USG). How do solve this: Trade Sanctions/Non Cooperation. Bitcoin is a similar development. > The straightforward response is that a contract to use a road should be scope-constrained to the topic of road usage, and not say also preclude you from using drugs on your own property. Agreed. > But that's no longer as simple and universal as a belief in unlimited contracts. Existence of unlimited contracts does not imply one have to agreed to one unreasonably. That is, think before agreeing to a contract (and arbitrator). Also note the contract to remove unlimited contracts would (probably) be unlimited itself.