4 ms·
I'm more interested in a study on stated vs observed behaviour re: paying for downloads. It's one thing to say that you'd pay, it's another to actually do so.
by roel_v 17y ago
I'm more interested in a study on stated vs observed behaviour re: paying for downloads. It's one thing to say that you'd pay, it's another to actually do so.
- barrkel 17y agoDon't forget that people already pay for their internet connection; this is existence proof they are willing to pay for access to this media (not that it goes to the producers). I sometimes wonder if it wouldn't be better to simply tax internet subscription revenue, and divide up the proceeds according to download statistics.
- Pheter 17y agoSure, paying for an internet connection means that they are willing to pay for access to media, but that could be because there is no alternative. If there was a way to 'pirate' an internet connection then what's to say they wouldn't do that too? And taxing internet subscription revenue is a terrible idea. Many people who pay for an internet connection do not pirate media, and in fact don't rarely purchase media whether physical or digital. Taxing these people for something that they don't want is unfair. Piracy is something that will always be around but the way to tackle it, imho, is to make obtaining it legally a more attractive option. Steam is a step in the right direction; if you pay for a game then you get a number of benefits that you otherwise wouldn't have if you pirated it.
- barrkel 17y agoI believe taxing subscription revenue would be more economically efficient than almost any micropayments architecture conceivable. I also don't think it's necessarily unfair on the whole; for example, consumer accounts with download caps may be taxed differently depending on the size of the cap. It's hard for most consumers to get near their bandwidth caps without consuming large amounts of media. And if there are other uses, e.g. remote work over VPNs, specific contracts with remote locations, etc., such traffic could be exempted from the taxable cap. One thing I'm pretty sure of: trying to sell information (i.e. bits) along the same lines as historical tokens (DVDs, CDs etc.) is doomed to failure. Steam comes with several major drawbacks: you need to be online regularly to log in, you have to put up with a client on every machine, forced advertising, higher prices than the shrinkwrapped box (the case here in the UK), etc. It's also a single point of failure in a business sense - size or past profitability is no guarantee against overreach or future bankruptcy, and the more eggs you have in the Steam basket, the more you have to lose when (and it will eventually) it goes away. Re pirating internet access: that's inherently different, because (most) information is a non-rivalrous good, while access to a network pipe is rivalrous.
- petercooper 17y agoIf there was a way to 'pirate' an internet connection then what's to say they wouldn't do that too? You're right. In the past (and probably ongoing now), there have been plenty of people illegally hooking up cable Internet and satellite connections. It's just not quite as easy compared to the price for most people. Heck, I'm ready to pay a lot more to get a much better service that they won't offer me..
- noss 17y agoSpotify seem to have problems converting users to premium paying users. The freemium users get breaks for commercials and cant use some spotify agents (mobile ones).
- pirko 17y agoSpotify have change the way I consume music. It's a great example of creating a service that makes it easier then the "free" illegal way. That's why I'm a paying subscriber. Both because I want to support them but also because I don't like to be interrupted by annoying commercials.
- baguasquirrel 17y agoAs it stands, you can get many games on Steam, Stardock, Direct2Drive and other services, but has that changed piracy much? It's a moot point, because the publishers will keep trying to put DRM in place "just in case". The question today is whether that DRM renders the game unplayable, like Settlers 7.
- roel_v 17y agoThis doesn't make sense. If there were no piracy, no publisher would put in DRM because it's an extra cost which no rational business owner would make if there weren't a need for it. Fact is that most people need to be kept honest with a way to enforce the license terms. Has been like this since the beginning of the commercial software / media market and I don't see a reason why it would change.
- froo 17y agoOne major thing to note is that this is an Australian study, so the perspective is Australian in nature. Obtaining content over here, legally, is incredibly difficult - even if you are trying to pay for it. I've said this for awhile (in fact, I said it on HN about a year ago) that there is something seriously wrong with the system when the path of least resistance to content for many consumers is not legal. We want to give the studios our money (this study while not comprehensive is at least indicative of a general feeling)... we just cant. I've often tried to obtain the latest content via itunes or wherever, it's simply not available in the vast majority of cases.
- roel_v 17y ago"One major thing to note is that this is an Australian study, so the perspective is Australian in nature." What makes this market special? Is there any reason to believe (e.g. when looking at software piracy numbers, which for the purposes of these discussions are comparable to other forms of copyright infringement) that Australians are more likely to abide by license terms than others, when put in a situation where they do have options that are non-infringing? The "we don't have access to legal ways of acquiring media" is a straw man argument most of the time that it's made, from my own observations. Introducing legal means does not reduce piracy rates in the cases where it has been tried so far, for example in the US or in Europe (I'm in Europe). Usually, as soon as online stores for music and video are introduced, the complaints shift to 'oh but it's too expensive'. I feel that 200k is too much for that Lamborghine Gallardo that I've go my eye on too, yet I don't hear anyone starting political parties trying to set a price ceiling on Italian sports cars, like in the digital goods world where so many are intent on trying to interrupt free markets and forcing content producers to sell their products under the price they deem optimal for the product they sell. I'm slipping into rant mode now, but a lot of online video stores have popped up the last year here in the Netherlands. Some shows are offered on one store, some on others, but in general (across all stores) there is quite a large selection available. Not everything you can get on DVD is available online, but that's hardly reasonable to expect. You know what the new complaint from the 'it's digital so it should be free!' freeloaders is? 'Oh those media conglomerates are evil, because we can't get everything from one store!'. That's ridiculous and in my eyes only shows that most of these people will not stop until there are laws in place to, by force of the state, steal the products of the minds of creators right from under them - to take from creators the rights to appropriate the products of their minds as they themselves see fit. 'from each according to his ability, to each according to his need' - yeah right, and those with the most needs just happen to be those with the least abilities. Screw them.
- philwelch 17y agoVery yes. It is one thing to say, hypothetically, "I would pay for X, but it's not available at a reasonable price, therefore I feel justified pirating." That's just plain old rationalization and self-justification at work. You just set some counterfactual terms and declare that since those terms aren't met, you're justified in doing what you're doing. Not a moral judgment, just an interesting observation.
- dkersten 17y agoWas wondering should I admit to piracy or not, but in the end, I bet most people here have pirated things at some point or another, so whatever. I used to pirate a lot of games. Sometimes I did it because the game didn't have a demo, or had a significantly crippled demo. Sometimes I did it because friends were trying to persuade me to get the game and I wanted to check out why. Sometimes I did it because I was pissed off at DRM and didn't want to buy a crippled version (spore, I'm looking at you). Sometimes I did it because I think €50 for a game with ten hours of gameplay is overpriced. Mostly it was a try before you buy thing - I own most of the games now that I pirated at one point or another. After getting one in a bundle, I will also never ever buy a Windows Live game. I was forced to restart because I couldn't save without logging in. It then wouldn't let me create an account because I didn't update. It then wouldn't update because of some bug. I had to google for twenty minutes to figure out a workaround for updating the game, download and install the updates and finally start the game from the start. Never again. Now I buy all my games, but I haven't bought a retail version in a long time. Occasionally I buy a boxed version online. Just yesterday I paid an extra ~€8 for a boxed version of Sins of a Solar Empire Trinity on Impulse (which I guess is the shipping cost). I now have 4 games purchased on Impulse, 34 on Steam and 4 I got elsewhere (just counted). Thats counting only digital download versions, I probably own another ~10 boxed games, though the retail ones are pretty old now. A lot (but not all) of those games I got discounted and some in bundles. Basically, if its easy for me to buy a downloadable game I want, I'll happily pay for it. If I really like the game, I'll even pay extra for a boxed version. I will NOT pay for a DRM crippled game and I refuse to pay €60 for games. In fact, I only pay over €30 for a game if I really really like it. If games are cheap enough (less than €10 for indy-style games; less than €20 for AAA games) then I'll impulse buy if the game looks good, even if I don't know anything about the game (I'll usually google it real quick and unless I find out that its terrible, has show stopper bugs or horrible DRM, I'll buy it). I impulse bought two games off the Direct2Drive spring sale for €4 each, for example. So: yes, I do pay for downloads. PS: I stopped watching (and therefore buying) DVD's after I was forced to watch UNSKIPPABLE TRAILERS on a DVD I paid for. I generally listen to non-chart music or listen online. Occasionally I buy mp3's.
- petercooper 17y agoI usually bleat on Twitter when I've found something I want and they simply won't let me buy it! Sometimes I go on to look for shady copies, but typically what I want is so niche I can't find any :-) Today's example: http://the99percent.com/book http://the99percent.com/book - a book I believe is popular in these circles. I want to read it on my iPad. I tried all the merchants and none sell a PDF and there's no Kindle edition. I can't use the iBookstore as I'm not in the US. It's not out in print in the UK yet either. It's funny because a great PDF excerpt is available. I just want to hand over money and get the full book as a PDF - it's not hard! There was also an indie album I was ready to buy. I went to preorder the MP3 edition, typed in my CC number and I could only select "USA" in the billing address! Order lost and a note in my calendar to look for the tracks when the album is released. So, I can't speak for everyone, but I'm finding stuff every month that I'd pay for in a heartbeat if it were in an open format and, well, if they'll accept payments from overseas.
- petercooper 17y agoThe company behind the book got in touch with me and suggested that this might let me buy a PDF to use: http://www.mobipocket.com/en/eBooks/eBookDetails.asp?BookID=282686 http://www.mobipocket.com/en/eBooks/eBookDetails.asp?BookID=... I'm not seeing any obvious sign of that but am currently investigating.