3 ms·
The article isn't about morality, it's about economics. The article didn't justify piracy in a moral sense by talking about people who wouldn't have bought it.
by barrkel 17y ago
The article isn't about morality, it's about economics.
The article didn't justify piracy in a moral sense by talking about people who wouldn't have bought it. He was trying to build an argument by saying most pirates wouldn't buy the games in any case, so that describing pirates as potential customers is erroneous, and therefore high piracy rates are not necessarily the cause of poor performance in the market.
The example of the iPhone was particularly good, I thought. From the numbers, it seems self-evident that app piracy isn't actually a big problem, even when most apps are pirated.
And for what it's worth, fairness has little to do with anything outside of childhood; there's no daddy you can go running to saying "it's not fair!", only economics, courts and politics, each with its own dynamics, but mostly coming down to power in bargaining.
- gyardley 17y agoWell, it's a problem when application developers operate a backend server to support their game - which isn't the most common thing to do, but it does happen. I've seen cases where piracy cut the developer's profits considerably because of this.
- naz 17y agoThe solution to this is to give each copy a cryptographic key which you then verify with the server. Unfortunately this isn't possible for iPhone games.