3 ms·
> I do not own the content on Netflix I did not buy it, I am renting a access licenses to a library of content for a monthly fee. You don't own the content wh
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> I do not own the content on Netflix I did not buy it, I am renting a access licenses to a library of content for a monthly fee.
You don't own the content when you buy a disc either. You own a copy.
Suppose you go out and buy a CD or DVD, make some fair use copies for whatever legitimate purposes you imagine, then when you're done you destroy the copies and sell the original disc on eBay.
Please explain why this is morally different than subscribing to Netflix and making fair use copies of the stream under the same circumstances.
- cryptarch 10y agoDoes U.S. fair use require you to destroy the fair use copies when you're no longer in posession of the original? I don't think so, I think you could even return it to the store, keep the backups and be perfectly legal. Perhaps intent matters?
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> Does U.S. fair use require you to destroy the fair use copies when you're no longer in posession of the original? I don't think so, I think you could even return it to the store, keep the backups and be perfectly legal. The point is to not argue about such things. Never mind what is and isn't fair use, imagine the strongest possible case for fair use that you can. Something that definitely is. Now in that case suppose the source is a Netflix stream rather than some physical medium. Why is that supposed to change anything? How is DRM OK in one case and not the other? There is no case where it doesn't prohibit you from doing something you have a right to do.
- cryptarch 10y agoI don't support DRM, I'm just wondering if I can buy music I like, rip them, and donate the CD's to my sorority. They need to keep copies of all CD's they play in the building as a protection against our local copyright groups BREIN and BUMA/STEMRA, otherwise they'd have to pay a monthly fee based on the total area music is played in. I think any restriction placed on general purpose computers ends up an assault on the whole thing. I agree with Cory Doctorow's thoughts [0] on this and it being an issue of human v. property rights. [0] https://boingboing.net/2012/01/10/lockdown.html https://boingboing.net/2012/01/10/lockdown.html