4 ms·
> We should attempt to study the pros and cons of each before drawing to conclusions. Already done. This has been studies exhaustively by the insurance indust
by austincheney 10y ago
> We should attempt to study the pros and cons of each before drawing to conclusions.
Already done. This has been studies exhaustively by the insurance industry and the criminal justice system. The age (of perpetrator) at which adult violent crimes most commonly occur is 18, which is the age of adulthood in most of the US. Secondly, it is 19. Then 20 and so forth up till the age of 24 after which there is no discernible pattern of violence to age. This pattern is largely attributed to the missing link between the prefrontal cortex and the limbic system of the brain.
I don't have any problem with alcohol and firearm sales being pushed to 25. If you want to shoot earlier then get private land outside a city, join a police department, join the military, or have a parent or guardian as a co-signer.
> Really? Do you have data to back this up?
Yeah, I think something like 6% of eligible voters aged 18-24 actually vote in presidential elections with a statistically insignificant amount of those voters voting in other elections.
> How are you going to hold those of age below 25 accountable?
Separate the 18-24 population into senior juveniles. Too old to be incarcerated with the violent children and too young to be bonded with the career criminals. Violent offenders absolutely should do time, but if they aren't adults should also have the opportunity to expunge their criminal record so as to allow them to obtain real jobs later.
- debaserab2 10y agoWhere is the data that backs up your 6% of eligible 18-24 year old voters claim?
- austincheney 10y agohttp://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CIRCLE_.. http://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CIRCLE_.... Turns out I was wrong. Youngsters aren't 6% of the vote, but closer to about 9%. Still tiny though. The data indicates people who are registered voters are about twice as likely to become a voter after the age of 25.
- skinnymuch 10y agoYou said 6% figure before too. Others have given links to disprOthers it. While you're just saying it. The quote you replied to asked for data. I don't think that meant just your words.
- austincheney 10y agohttp://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CIRCLE_.. http://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CIRCLE_.... Turns out I was wrong. Youngsters aren't 6% of the vote, but closer to about 9%. Still tiny though. The data indicates people who are registered voters are about twice as likely to become a voter after the age of 25.
- Fnoord 10y ago> I don't have any problem with alcohol and firearm sales being pushed to 25. If you want to shoot earlier then get private land outside a city, join a police department, join the military, or have a parent or guardian as a co-signer. I'm baffled at how at one side you argue the legal age should be raised, while you suggest youth should join the military or the police. Jobs which include firearms, and a high sense of responsibility. At the same time, you want to remove accountability from said youth? If you take away so many responsibilities from youth, why keep police/military around for them? I really don't believe 6% (or, for that matter 9% (50% more)) of eligible voters ages 18-24 in my country vote. Perhaps the problem is local or US specific. Also, we don't know the why. I would like to see the US data cross referenced with data from other countries. I also read that heroin has overtaken gun shootings in cause of dead. Heroin, an illegal drug. We can make services illegal if they require a government license, but goods? Difficult to make illegal. > Separate the 18-24 population into senior juveniles. Too old to be incarcerated with the violent children and too young to be bonded with the career criminals. Violent offenders absolutely should do time, but if they aren't adults should also have the opportunity to expunge their criminal record so as to allow them to obtain real jobs later. An interesting point, but nonetheless if you put criminals together you beget criminals. Instead, all the progressive research I've seen is that investing in people integrating in society has a much lower chance to stop recidivism. Although in the US there's little to no interest in such because the US profits from people incarcerated via cheap/free labour.
- austincheney 10y ago> At the same time, you want to remove accountability from said youth? If you take away so many responsibilities from youth, why keep police/military around for them? Accountability is not an earned quality. Accountability is an appointed quality. By raising the age of adulthood you are deferring the age of accountability (in the realm of individual responsibility) to a later age when the individual is better prepared and perhaps more responsible. As far police and military individual responsibility is less a consideration because you are on a job with extensive training and constant supervision. Additionally, people in these job classes are held to higher legal standards and are punished more harshly for violations of the public trust. > I would like to see the US data cross referenced with data from other countries. I suspect a lower percentage of the population in the US votes compared to other equally democratic nations for all age demographics. > Instead, all the progressive research I've seen I really think this is more a separate conversation, but certainly there are many various huge opportunities for improvement in how the US manages its criminal population.