13 ms·
Imagine if we followed the numbers, the empirical evidence, like insurance companies do. In this case the legal age would be raised from 18 to 25. This wouldn
by austincheney 10y ago
Imagine if we followed the numbers, the empirical evidence, like insurance companies do. In this case the legal age would be raised from 18 to 25. This wouldn't make any real difference to politics because young people don't vote. It would be huge to consumer spending. Consider the following:
* Age to get a credit card, file a DBA, open a bank account, or get an apartment.
* Age to purchase tobacco and pornography (yes yes, I suspect most people get their porn for free online regardless of age now).
* FBI already refuses to hire field agents below the age of 24.
* You could not be tried as an adult in criminal court until age 25. The number of adult violent offenders in prison might decrease as much as 70%.
* You cannot get married until the age of adulthood. I suspect states would compromise on this one and allow permissible parental consent as young people will still continue to have children.
---
My personal opinions are that people would be much better prepared for life, there would be fewer lost souls to the criminal justice system, and the consumer debt industry would be largely eliminated from all but proverty classes (like the payday loan vultures).
- tutanchamun 10y ago> This wouldn't make any real difference to politics because young people don't vote What can young people change in the midterm future anyway? The population is becoming more and more a inverted pyramid where the old people are the majority and the young people are the minority. A voting system which adjusts the voting power based on the age would be interesting. If old people are a minoity the get more voting power until they are equal and vice versa. I believe with something like that the brexit vote would not have happened.
- JoeAltmaier 10y ago35% over 50. Is that an inverted pyramid? Seems like a regular pyramid. I think voting demographics indeed has to be explained by "young people don't vote".
- philh 10y agoAnd a lot of 18-25 year olds would be prohibited from living independently. This would be terrible, for example, for people in abusive households. And it would merely suck horribly for anyone who simply chafes at not being treated like a person.
- austincheney 10y agoI don't see how that would make any difference. Typically many 18 year old require a co-signer or sponsor to get an apartment on their own. If you are in an abusive household call the authorities (you can do this at any age).
- r_smart 10y agoYeah, this. As someone who moved out at 18, please don't force people to have to stay in bad living arrangements any longer than they need to.
- colanderman 10y agoYou forget two things: 1) Our military is largely composed of 18-24 year olds. We would be sending legal children to war. 2) The purpose of democratic voting is not to decide policy, it is to give legitimacy to policy decisions. When you disenfranchise a large number of people who believe themselves capable of decision-making, and who tend to disagree with the majority opinion, you risk revolts. Note in particular the disastrous consequences of the product of these two issues. 18 is just fine.
- austincheney 10y agoThis happens anyways. I joined the US Army at age 17. I think your second point is reactionary to the extreme. It would be more valid if young people participated (actually by voting and/or petitioning the government) instead of just bitching about it on social media. That said young people can revolt just the same regardless of voting age.
- jacalata 10y agoI thought there was some caveat like you can join but you can't be sent off to combat until 18? And his point was that if your army is composed of people who aren't allowed to vote you are setting yourself up for higher risk.
- cmdrfred 10y agoWhen you join the armed forces they don't just stick a gun in your hand and fly to you Iraq, the training you receive will bring you to 18 before you are deployed.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ipnon 10y agoThe article mentions that logical thinking, such as that used when voting for political candidates, is fully developed by 16. Therefore, it would be reasonable to lower the age of citizenship to the age of 16, citizenship being the right to vote and the right to join the armed forces. The author of this article and the scientist who published this research share the same conclusion. It is emotional processing that goes undeveloped until the late 20's.
- Fnoord 10y ago> Age to purchase tobacco and pornography (yes yes, I suspect most people get their porn for free online regardless of age now). You didn't include alcohol which is already at the age of 21 in USA, but not everywhere else in the world (in my country, it is 18). Yet driving, is age 16 in USA, 18 here as well. My point is that the world is bigger than just a few countries, with different age limits. We should attempt to study the pros and cons of each before drawing to conclusions. Also, the fact something (e.g. alcohol) is illegal to purchase doesn't mean it cannot be obtained. With driving a car that is going to be more difficult because the car is licensed to a person, and learning driving via obtaining driver's license is important. On the longer term, driving a car becomes irrelevant though, but I suspect the same is true for tobacco. You also didn't mention that other hot subject, firearms. > This wouldn't make any real difference to politics because young people don't vote. Really? Do you have data to back this up? I know that, from personal experience, I voted as soon as I became 18. > open a bank account I think I was able to open a bank account at age 12. Not that there was a whole lot on it. That's OK, it allows youth to learn how financials work and managing money. What is not OK is allowing youth to get in debt. The only loans a student (read: 18+) is able to get is via the government, for studies, and they gotta be paid back. I don't see a problem with that system, in the sense that is must be abolished. I think it is great to have young people work. It teaches them what they want, and not want to do. It stimulates them to start a study, put their heart and soul in it, and finish it. Because who wants to pluck berries for the rest of their life? Only those who never done it before. > * You could not be tried as an adult in criminal court until age 25. The number of adult violent offenders in prison might decrease as much as 70%. How are you going to hold those of age below 25 accountable? The justice system exists to find balance between 'damage received', and 'damage done'. If those who cause damage are not going to be held accountable in any way then that does not seem justifiable to me. However I would agree that a young person should receive, generally, less penalty than an older one. We got a reasonable system for that already: we punishing recidivists more heavy. My opinion on the whole matter: the term young adult exists for a reason. Part of puberty and being a teen is getting lose from the stigma and lack of responsibilities associated with being a child. We need to let our children taste how it is to be an adult and all of the above are part of exposure. If we treat young adult as if they're children, they are going to remain children and will get a revelation when they reach adult age (in your PoV that should be 25).
- digi_owl 10y ago> This wouldn't make any real difference to politics because young people don't vote. Not quite. They do not vote on "old people". Why? Anything from simply age to not feeling older people understand their world and situation.
- austincheney 10y agoI have no idea what that means. Statistically young people don't vote. I think its close to around 6% of 18-24 year olds vote in presidential elections with a statistically insignificant amount voting in other elections.
- debaserab2 10y agoI don't know where you got those numbers from. The lowest I can find is in the 30% range for a presidential election. It's a bit disingenuous to write that off completely. http://www.electproject.org/home/voter-turnout/demographics http://www.electproject.org/home/voter-turnout/demographics
- austincheney 10y agohttp://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CIRCLE_.. http://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CIRCLE_.... Turns out I was wrong. Youngsters aren't 6% of the vote, but closer to about 9%. Still tiny though. The data indicates people who are registered voters are about twice as likely to become a voter after the age of 25.
- ianburrell 10y agoYou are confused about the difference between percentage of youngsters who vote, which is 40%, and the percentage of the total vote that are youngsters, which is 9%. But 18-24 is probably only 10% of the voting population.
- debaserab2 10y agoThat link didn't work for me.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>In this case the legal age would be raised from 18 to 25. This wouldn't make any real difference to politics because young people don't vote. Not to complain, but I sure as hell voted. I checked, and 46% of "young people" (Millenials) do vote regularly. So, uh, thanks for trying to take our rights away.
- pdx 10y ago> So, uh, thanks for trying to take our rights away. The OP was engaging in discussion, not seriously advocating a course of action. When you're older, you won't take offense so easily.
- philh 10y ago> The OP was engaging in discussion, not seriously advocating a course of action. This is an important distinction to make, but it's not a black-and-white one. And while OP didn't literally say "I think we should take rights from 18-24 year olds", they do seem to be arguing in that direction. > When you're older, you won't take offense so easily. Please don't condescend.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoI especially ask you to avoid condescension since it's been a few years since I was in the 18-25 bracket.
- austincheney 10y agohttp://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CIRCLE_2013FS_outhVoting2012FINAL.pdf http://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CIRCLE_... Turns out I was wrong. Youngsters aren't 6% of the vote, but closer to about 9%. Still tiny though. The data indicates people who are registered voters are about twice as likely to become a voter after the age of 25.
- Fnoord 10y agoWhat? 9%? Check table 1 in your source. "Table 1: Voter Turnout Among Citizens November 2000, 2004, 2008, and 2012 18-29 40% 49% 51% 45% [...]" It was 45% in 2012 for the age of 18-29.
- closeparen 10y agoThis presupposes that the brain development between 18 and 25 would still happen if 18-25 was still childhood. Do we have reason to believe that people can mature fully before being allowed to make decisions, that it's 100% about time and 0% about practice? Note, debt is a huge problem for people don't have earning power yet. If 25 is the new 18, we should expect 25-year-olds to have the same financial instability as current 18-year-olds as they will be on similarly shaky ground in the workforce.
- Qiasfah 10y agoChanging the legal age in this manner would have had serious negative effects on my life. Frankly this idea horrifies me. Let me explain: -A job I had in highschool enabled me to buy my own car and pay for insurance at 17 (added as a driver to my parents plan of course). -I got my first credit card at 18 when I went to college, I have never carried a balance on it month to month (I'm now 26) -The last time I lived with my parents was the summer after my freshmen year in college -I graduated with an engineering degree at the age of 21 -I've had a steady fulfilling engineering job for 4.5 years since graduation -I met my current wife freshmen year of college and we got married a year after graduation -In 2014 I bought a house based purely of my personal credit history and employment status -I have voted in every presidential election despite not being actively involved in politics I'm sure I fall well outside the typical statistics for someone of my age, and I've been very lucky so far. Lots of my coworkers are in a similar situation as me, but there's also lots of people in the opposite situation. Do you see why this horrifies me? Do you think these ideas would be positive for the young adults that have found success in life? (Edited for line break formatting)
- btkramer9 10y agoI came here to say the exact same thing. I'm pretty much following the same timeline as you where I'm 23 at the moment. I couldn't wait to take on responsibilities of my own. Bills, rent, everything. I've always wondered if these stats are partially affected by the 'legal age' itself. If it were changed would the age groups for risky drivers, high probability of crime and debt shift with it?
- Kluny 10y agoAgreed, let's not infantilize the people who can function as adults just to coddle those who can't! I moved out of my parents house at age 17. Although they are good parents, responsible people, and I love them, I was miserable and suicidal when I lived with them. I wasn't able to learn how to be happy and social until I moved out on my own, to a city where there were more people like me, and gained some independence. I've never had any debt or trouble paying bills, I've voted in every election as well. I got all my binge drinking out of my system when I was 19. If I had been forced to remain under my parents control until age 25 (just 2 years ago!) I would have been miserable, resentful and angry about it. It would definitely have destroyed my relationship with my parents.
- michaelchisari 10y agoIn this case the legal age would be raised from 18 to 25. Isn't this the opposite of the conclusion that one of the scientists interviewed came to? Dr. Steinberg agreed with Dr. Somerville that the maturing of the brain was proving to be a long, complicated process without obvious milestones. Nevertheless, he thinks recent studies hold some important lessons for policy makers. He has proposed, for example, that the voting age be lowered to 16. “Sixteen-year-olds are just as good at logical reasoning as older people are,” Dr. Steinberg said.
- vinay427 10y agoSome sixteen-year olds are able to vote in some municipalities, for what it's worth. I would personally support having different ages for different things instead of a catch-all age of 18 for adulthood.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoThis might be an edge case but it's worth bringing up that this would just delay the amount of time before kids in a myriad of bad situations at home can escape. There are kids in situations where abuse is difficult to prove and the longer they're near them the harder it can be for the child to leave or remove their harmful influence. A parent with narcissistic personality disorder for example.
- projektir 10y agoI think there's a reason we do not just blindly follow the numbers. They can lie just as much, sometimes more. I'm a bit alarmed that this comment is upvoted so highly, given the criticisms of fMRI studies just below. Haven't we learned something from all the replicability issues? If you want people to be prepared for life, you need to prepare them for life. This life is hard to live, and we mostly just throw people to the wolves and act surprised when they get eaten. Waiting extra years will not magically impart them with missing wisdom, and all the people who end up in the criminal justice system likely have poor families and will only be worse off having to spend even more time with them. I would, to the contrary, would like to see more means for independence. I'm still not sure why parents need to subsidize everything.
- benmmurphy 10y agocouldn't people offending at a higher rate between 18-25 compare to beyond 25 be a kind of survival bias thing. like if you are more likely to commit a crime then you are more likely to be in jail >25 than 18-25.
- slavik81 10y agoA significant number of people never become truly responsible adults. Even just narrowing it down to political engagement, lots of voters are poorly informed about the issues they vote on. Even if you disenfranchise young people there will be countless stupid, ignorant and hateful people voting. Even worse, they'll mostly have the biases of old people because you'll have entirely removed the opposing biases of young people. Finally, on a personal note, I was working and paying taxes from the age of 16. No taxation without representation.
- hx87 10y agoAs long as there was a standardized, transparent way to emancipate yourself and prove your readiness before that age, I'd support your proposal. In fact, why not get rid of the "automatic adulthood at given age" system at all so that everyone could attain adulthood only through the emancipation process?
- srssays 10y ago> You cannot get married until the age of adulthood. I suspect states would compromise on this one and allow permissible parental consent as young people will still continue to have children. Course you can. The US doesn't have a monopoly on marriage. Scotland has historically had more lax requirements for marriage than England (and still to this day the age of unconditional age of marriage is 16 in Scotland but 18 in England). So English couples who couldn't get their parents' permission just went to Gretna Green past the Scottish border to get married. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gretna_Green#Marriage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gretna_Green#Marriage
- arise 10y agoYou forget that the empirical evidence is influenced by our cultural norms (such as children not leaving home until 18). If you (further) shelter/protect/structure young twenty-somethings, they'll grow up even slower, and fifty years hence a poster like you will be suggesting we raise the age of adulthood from 25 to 30. Perhaps we should help kids grow up faster by giving them more experiences and responsibilities.