5 ms·
There's plenty of garbage to be learned either from books or from personal experience. I'm not trying to be flippant. As you pointed out, we all have our biase
by klodolph 10y ago
There's plenty of garbage to be learned either from books or from personal experience. I'm not trying to be flippant.
As you pointed out, we all have our biases. If I were raised racist, I'd try to confirm those biases in my personal experiences. Or perhaps some kind of personal experience would shatter my biases. I could be on the lookout for things I hear on talk radio, or I could make unexpected friends. Equally, I could get my sense of morals from reading Ayn Rand, Nietzsche, St. Augustine, or the Dhammapada. I've known people who have learned atrocious or wonderful things from books, and I've known people who have invented fantastic or horrifying personal philosophies. I don't think I've uncovered any kind of pattern as to why some people think one way and others another.
The funny thing here is that in this discussion, we're using our personal experiences (anecdotes and armchair speculation) to try and analyze it.
My personal contribution is that older people have more property, and that whatever material they use for their political views (be it books or experiences) will mostly be used to support their own goals for enjoying that property. The young folks want to get property, so they vote for that instead. That doesn't explain much, but it does partly explain why younger citizens tend to be more liberal.
- tormeh 10y agoYes, and young people have little property and therefore don't have that much to lose from change. Old people are conservative because they have property - the less change the better.
- croon 10y agoPolarizing question, but I wonder how many people who hold up an Ayn Rand book as a marker for their views have actually read it, and how much they read otherwise. I think it's very rare for people who do read a lot, and read varied to not be "better" off than not reading. Like most I was an idealist in youth, and while I have become more pragmatic, I still try to stoke that fire. I however learned in my 20s to never fear the opposition/unknown, and reading more and challenging views is never dangerous. Sometimes it challenges you to rethink your stance, sometimes it's exposed as ridiculous. My point is that I think it's really hard to "learn garbage" from reading a lot.
- klodolph 10y agoConsider my viewpoint as one in opposition to your own. My personal experience—I've met people who are well read but don't read well, if you know what I mean. People who read Nietzcshe and think that they can get by with less sleep because they're übermensch. Yes, I've actually met two people who have come to that particular conclusion. I imagine that they eventually grew out of it, but was it reading, specifically that caused this, or just the general experience of life (of which reading is one part)? If your attitude is that you are reading to challenge yourself with views that you disagree with, then you are going to find it easier to expand your mind. But that's not why everyone reads, not everything you read will expand your mind, and that kind of attitude will allow you to expand your mind in many other ways as well (besides reading). I'm also not sold on the idea that youth are idealists in some kind of ideological sense. I feel that it comes across that way, but only because as I get older, I am a better judge of how I can actually change the world, and I might as well devote my resources to where I can make the biggest difference. In other words, we may become more or less idealist as we get older, but being pragmatic is literally a skill that requires experience to develop. And if you doubt that you are still idealistic, remember that you are the one arguing that it's hard to "learn garbage" from reading—perhaps an ideological standpoint, from my perspective ;-)
- hliyan 10y agoI'd like to think that the ideals/principles of youth and old are the same, except that the old have been patched over the years for real world vulnerabilities.
- croon 10y agoI'll gladly consider your viewpoint in opposition to mine, because it would mean that I grew from it, since I agree with a lot of what you're saying as I'm reading it ;) I suppose I can't know how other people are affected by what and how much they read other than from my own experience and empathic hypotheticals. Is it a question of the much talked about view of fixed/growth mindsets? I knew I knew everything at 17, and obviously I was wrong. I grow less knowledgable by the year, while reading more. I'm not saying anything profound here that hasn't been said by Lao Tsu, Einstein, Aristotle, Emerson, etc. Are you suggesting that this is not universal truth but merely true for those eager to learn? I suppose I could surrender that merely picking up a book you on the offset disagree with requires a will to be challenged. And once again, I'm less certain of something than I was going in. Time to rebuild my world view. Thanks.