3 ms·
> Why should you really help someone who lives down the street from you over someone 10 miles away? Why someone 30 miles away over someone 300 miles away? Becau
by mistermann 10y ago
> Why should you really help someone who lives down the street from you over someone 10 miles away? Why someone 30 miles away over someone 300 miles away? Because circumstance led you to randomly live near them?
Maybe because you've been through hardships together, maybe your neighbors ancestors owe yours a tremendous debt of gratitude, numerous reasons that I doubt refugees from most anywhere in the world would find difficult to understand.
Also, this thing called war used to affect us in the west, where the comfortable living of the last 70 odd years seems to have completely wiped any memories from the earlier difficult periods from our collective consciousness. The very idea of forming tightly knit bonds with your neighbors, and saving in times of plenty for the inevitable times of hardship that lie down the road, is now considered not just passe, but foolish.
- meowface 10y ago>Maybe because you've been through hardships together Maybe, but that's a special exception. Usually this is not the case. >maybe your neighbors ancestors owe yours a tremendous debt of gratitude Who cares about ancestors? If my ancestor was a murderer, do I have to honor his legacy? I couldn't care less what my ancestors did, unless I've interacted with them while they were still alive. As for war: that's the one big exception. Of course nationalism is required during war. But the West is not currently in a state of war.
- mistermann 10y ago> Who cares about ancestors? Almost everyone.
- meowface 10y agoI don't know about that. Ask a random American how they feel about their dead great-grandfather, and you'd probably get an answer like "indifferent". Of course, I know it's different in many non-Western cultures.
- mistermann 10y agoSadly, you're most likely right.