3 ms·
Court tells FCC: you don't have this authority under the laws passed by elected officials. FCC says: we'll grant ourselves the authority by bureaucratic fiat!
by gojomo 17y ago
Court tells FCC: you don't have this authority under the laws passed by elected officials.
FCC says: we'll grant ourselves the authority by bureaucratic fiat!
No committee of 5 partisan appointees -- guaranteed by formula to be 3 members of the president's party, and 2 from the opposition party -- should have this much power over something as fundamental as "communication".
Would we let the FCC reclassify printing presses as a "transport service", and thus subject to their regulations about ownership, subsidized access, suitable proportion of "public interest" content, and naughty words?
Do we want the internet to be as diverse as unregulated books and magazines, or as pandering to the-powers-that-be as FCC-regulated broadcast TV?
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoYou are noising the point. The court doesn't want the FCC regulating info seevices like transport services, which makes sense. So, the FCC is saying "you're right" to the court and is treating broadband as a transport service, which it is. Broadband is more like a telephone call than a stream of ticker updates.
- gojomo 17y agoInteractive any-to-any broadband is more like speech itself, or a free press, than it is like either a telephone call or a TV station.
- _delirium 17y agoA provider of retail last-mile internet service is much more like a provider of retail last-mile telephone lines, though. Often it's even the same physical line!
- hga 17y agoExcept that the current word is that the FCC chairman is looking for a "third way"....