5 ms·
We've been splitting atoms for 70 years. France has run its electric grid on 80% nuclear power. What's our track record on reducing consumption and population?
by DennisP 10y ago
We've been splitting atoms for 70 years. France has run its electric grid on 80% nuclear power. What's our track record on reducing consumption and population?
Not saying we shouldn't do them all, but I don't think nuclear is the most difficult of these three.
- jat850 10y agoMy thoughts too. I would go further and say that at our current point in time, splitting atoms is easier than reducing population, and maybe easier than reducing consumption.
- omegaworks 10y ago>What's our track record on reducing consumption and population? As for the latter, it's great actually. Lifting people out of poverty and keeping their kids alive lowers their birth rate.
- DennisP 10y agoGlobally we haven't reduced population, we've just reduced its rate of increase. Our success rate on actually reducing global population is zero. And generally, lifting people out of poverty has meant increasing their carbon emissions.
- smaddox 10y agoFrance was able to run at 80% fission because they were selling excess production at low domestic demand times to adjacent territories. If you want to use nuclear for more than base load, you run into similar storage/transmission issues to solar/wind. Either way, we need a larger and more capable grid, so that production and demand can be balanced over larger areas.
- KVFinn 10y ago>Either way, we need a larger and more capable grid, so that production and demand can be balanced over larger areas. Yup. Larger power markets benefits every kind of power: wind, solar, and nuclear. There is a lot of resistance to this though. Every state would prefer wind sites build in their own state, rather than buying power from the windier state farther away. If you had a truly national sized grid then the power distribution between even just wind and solar is remarkably stable.
- p0nce 10y agoYes we have to support nuclear over-production during summer and store it with dams. Yet this winter we'll be under-capacity, lots of reactors are currently shutdown because of maintenance.
- DennisP 10y agoModern nuclear plants are able to load follow [1]. The main reason we use them for base load is that nuclear's cost is mainly fixed, so it makes economic sense to run them at full capacity and follow demand with fossil, which has lower fixed costs and higher variable costs. Molten salt reactors would be quite good at load following, because the reaction rate slows down so much as the fuel temperature increases. If you draw less power, you apply less cooling, so the fuel heats and the power output goes down. For example, the IMSR, likely the first MSR to be commercialized, is naturally a load-following reactor [2]. This doesn't mean it wouldn't make economic sense to, say, run nuclear for baseload, add solar for extra daytime demand, and use storage to smooth out the remaining demand mismatch. But that's a matter of economic optimization, not a technical limitation of nuclear. [1] http://ansnuclearcafe.org/2013/02/14/responding-to-system-demand/#sthash.VRgqQpEI.dpbs http://ansnuclearcafe.org/2013/02/14/responding-to-system-de... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSR#Control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSR#Control
- smaddox 10y agoIMSR looks like promising technology, but it's not yet proven. I'm hopeful Terrestrial Energy succeeds in commercializing it and competing with existing energy sources (without subsidies). Even if they do, it will not be a one size fits all solution, though. In contrast, we know with near certitude that investment in basic infrastructure, such as a capable and robust power grid, will promote a plurality of solutions and pay for itself over time.
- thinkcontext 10y ago"What's our track record on reducing consumption and population?" EU28 and Japanese electric consumption is falling. Population is falling in Japan and is in some EU countries (Germany) and likely will on average in the EU in the not too distant future.