3 ms·
I can't even imagine the amount of fear I'd feel if someone asked me to make some modifications to an antique violin worth millions of dollars. It'd be like dep
by onion2k 10y ago
I can't even imagine the amount of fear I'd feel if someone asked me to make some modifications to an antique violin worth millions of dollars. It'd be like deploying an update on a Friday afternoon.
- analog31 10y agoThe fear would be palpable, but on most of those instruments, the modifications were done in the 19th century, as the modern violin was developed. They changed the size and shape of the bass bar, and the geometry of the neck. Also, the materials and construction techniques all lend themselves to repairability. Just holding one of those instruments would make me nervous, but in terms of both maintenance and use, they were made to be played. This is just something that people accept. I obviously don't play a Strad (he didn't make double basses, that's my excuse), but when I got a nice new bass, people asked me if I'd ever take it out of the house, or if I'd use my old bass for performances. I tell people the same thing, it was made to be played.
- dyim 10y agoIt'd be like deploying an update before leaving for your honeymoon!
- manarth 10y agoNow imagine leaving it on a train: http://www.thelocal.de/20160108/violinist-forgets-24-million-stradivarius-on-train http://www.thelocal.de/20160108/violinist-forgets-24-million...
- dahart 10y agoAt least a deploy you can fix or roll back. Break a Strad or Guarneri, and you're done.
- mikestew 10y agoMmm, not necessarily. Someone took a fireplace poker to Bill Monroe's mandolin. Someone managed to put it back together: http://www.mandolinarchive.com/perl/show_mando.pl?55 http://www.mandolinarchive.com/perl/show_mando.pl?55 (The last picture shows the damage, first one shows its restored state.)
- dahart 10y agoYes, necessarily, we're talking about the financial value of a Strad. I'm well aware of how fixable wooden instruments are, but break a Strad, and you lose millions. Irrevocably.
- pge 10y agoGood to see another bluegrass fan on HN! (I'm a mandolin player myself, and I think our fascination with Loar F5s is similar to violinists' obsession with Strads)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- owenversteeg 10y agoHah, I can't compare to that, but I do some minor violin-fixing stuff as a hobby. Recently I spent a decent amount of time repairing a 100 year old German violin, and (at first) it's exactly like you describe: you feel like you're going to destroy everything. Like you're playing football with a Prince Rupert's Drop. But then you get into a bit of a pattern with the instrument, and you start to feel more confident... which funny enough isn't a good thing, cause that's when you screw up. Make no mistake, I love it though, and the finished product is absolutely gorgeous.
- elihu 10y agoI've repaired a few violins, none of them expensive or valuable. One of them I had gotten at Goodwill for $20 or so with a couple cracks in the top. Popping the top off of the violin was a little nerve-wracking, but that cracking-hide-glue sound is also satisfying. It went back together nicely (I even used the opportunity to glue a piezo-film transducer to the inside of the soundboard). Now I don't feel quite so much like the violin I'm holding is going to shatter into a million pieces if I twist too hard on a tuning peg.