3 ms·
I would be interested in anybody over 40 who thinks things are much the same as they were before, and anybody under 20 who thinks the guy is on to something. L
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I would be interested in anybody over 40 who thinks things are much the same as they were before, and anybody under 20 who thinks the guy is on to something.
Lots of generational bias in the comments so far.
I know I've seen the drift, and I strongly suspect that shame, guilt, and embarrassment serve a greater societal function than we give them credit for. The discussion is very reminiscent to me of the free love movement back in the 1960s. Everybody wondered why you just couldn't turn on, tune in, drop out, and have all the sex you wanted. Love one another. Sounded great. Then the societal bill came due, and it wasn't pretty -- STDs, junkies, crime, rapes, lost lives, the me generation. Looked great on paper. Didn't work so well in reality. My feeling is that this TMI stuff is going to turn out the same way. But I'm as biased as the next guy.
- tptacek 17y agoSo then by your logic, the Victorian era should have been a "societal" golden age. But: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syphilis#Notable_syphilis-infected_people_in_history http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syphilis#Notable_syphilis-infec...
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoHuh? No, by my logic, traditions develop for a reason. Learn the reason and do what you like. Having a lot of tradition and social norms isn't good -- neither is having none. You're just as idiotic throwing it all out the window as you are accepting it as the unalterable truth. Moderation my friend. Understanding and moderation. Adapting and changing things is awesome. Let's do more of that. But let's not be idiotic about it. EDIT: I work in hi-tech with people changing the world. I love startups. My goal in life is to change people's lives for the better. I'm always talking about the singularity and how great change for the better is on the way. And now I'm a Victorian. Go figure.
- tptacek 17y agoI'm not saying you're a Victorian. I'm saying that during a culture where shame and social norming were at their height, most of the "societal" problems you attribute to the 70's were epidemic.
- crystalis 17y agoPerish the thought of lackabouts that arose from anything less than an entire generation's misdeeds! If it weren't for the free love movement of the 60s, no one would have ever wasted their life in an opium den! All those poor doomed souls...
- jbange 17y agoActually, STDs, crime, rape, junkies, and lost lives have been civilization's constant companion for millennia. There was definitely a tradition of pretending it wasn't happening prior to the late 60's/early 70's, but if you think people weren't getting high, screwing around, and beating the crap out of each other before then, and in similar numbers, you truly have no grasp of the history of humanity.