3 ms·
> (whether or not it is, in fact, legal, under current EU law). It was looked into, for years, by a team of lawyers on behalf of the ECC (as you could read in
by Fnoord 10y ago
> (whether or not it is, in fact, legal, under current EU law).
It was looked into, for years, by a team of lawyers on behalf of the ECC (as you could read in the other recent article).
The article in this HN thread also links to an analysis by US lawyer Richard A. Epstein. Here it is once more [1]. Interestingly, Epstein is a critic of the EC: "My initial judgment—always subject to revision on the strength of additional information—is that the EC was correct in its decision. In making this assessment, I admit that I harbor a deep suspicion of the EC in its multiple roles. In general, there is much to the charge that the EC’s policies are prejudiced against American companies that do business in the EU. But it is one thing to start with a strong presumption, and another to put the pieces together in a prudent fashion." and "At its root, the Apple decision rests on premises far removed from Warren’s progressivism. It makes a classical liberal argument in favor of free trade across national boundaries. Though the EC often acts as a statist institution, it has made a sound economic decision by taking on an American icon that deserves to have its wings clipped." (Note, the article is interesting far beyond what I quote, and I highly recommend reading it, but I have to quote selectively to make my point.)
If Apple believes it is unlawful they should argue that, but as the article says they're playing the pity card and resort to other fallacies. If your opponent uses appeal to pity and ad hominem attacks that says enough since that is the two lowest of Graham's hierarchy of disagreement (the disagreement pyramid) [2]
[1] http://www.hoover.org/research/europe-gets-apple-right http://www.hoover.org/research/europe-gets-apple-right
[2] http://www.conceptdraw.com/examples/paul-graham-disagreement-pyramid http://www.conceptdraw.com/examples/paul-graham-disagreement...