4 ms·
This trajectory has been going for perhaps a few decades, but human embarrassment is thousands of years old. So you can't just say "Oh, old people always think
by jessriedel 17y ago
This trajectory has been going for perhaps a few decades, but human embarrassment is thousands of years old. So you can't just say "Oh, old people always think young people are too risque. Get over it." There is some structure to the current trend, and it seems worthwhile to try to explain it (though the OP fails, IMO).
Now, that doesn't mean that the threshold for human embarrassment has been static since before the industrial revolution; looking at history, it has certainly varied dramatically across time and space. It's probably not random, so tracing it's cause would be interesting.
Further, I don't think many people are going to go to the extreme relativist standpoint and say that all thresholds for embarrassment are equally (un-)valuable. It's not hard to make arguments for why it's a good thing people are too embarrassed to have sex in public (though I'm sure there are a few extreme bullet-biters). So then the question is, can you defend what you think is an optimal threshold for embarrassment, whether or not it coincides with the current threshold? The OP doesn't seem to be able to defend his, but that doesn't mean it shouldn't/can't be done.
- potatolicious 17y ago> " It's not hard to make arguments for why it's a good thing people are too embarrassed to have sex in public" Why? Not that I'd do it mind you - but that's a limitations in how I've been raised. When I think about it, there's nothing really objectively wrong about having sex in public.
- jessriedel 17y agoFor a reason related to, but not the same as, the reason sexual modesty evolved (which only exists in social species): because sex is a method to emotionally bond two people together in a way which is pretty much impossible to do otherwise because of the way humans are hardwired. This aspect of sex would be seriously diminished if it was routinely done in public because the participants would have their "social guard" up (that is, they would necessarily be concerned with signaling to others in their group/tribe). EDIT: Also, I should point out that your sexual modesty is more strongly determined by your genes than your upbringing. Sexual modesty is universal across human culture, even among people who have been raised in bizarre cults which tried to eliminate such modesty.
- crystalis 17y agoSaying "cuz your jeans did it~~" doesn't support your argument terribly well; you've demonstrated why things are, but not why they should be, or why we shouldn't mimic the cuckoo bird or the ant fungus, or why we shouldn't try to prevent sickle cell anemia because our genes would like it that way but they're too modest to speak up.
- jessriedel 17y agoI said that sexual modesty is crucial to forming human partnerships and I said specifically that its moral worth is distinct from its evolutionary origin. Do I also need to justify why human partnerships are good?
- crystalis 17y agoI've got close bonds with friends, and I didn't need to sleep with any of them! I'm sure most startups have managed that too, even if some of them may have benefited from it. Monogamy, too, is natural, and may be a contributing factor for domestic violence, crimes of passion, an incredible divorce rate, and patriarchal oppression.