3 ms·
Hmmm...I would respectfully disagree :). While it would most certainly impact stores by reducing cash clerks etc. people would still be required for warehousing
by pm90 10y ago
Hmmm...I would respectfully disagree :). While it would most certainly impact stores by reducing cash clerks etc. people would still be required for warehousing/monitoring etc. A lot of high volume retailers/grocers already have a self-checkout station, if they had wanted more automation, they would probably just increase the number of these stations.
Also, anything more than a basic grocer would still want real people to help people with purchasing etc.
- notheguyouthink 10y ago> A lot of high volume retailers/grocers already have a self-checkout station, if they had wanted more automation, they would probably just increase the number of these stations. I mean, this is a great example against your point (imo). Those self checkout stands, sure they do employ a staffer to monitor, but each of those stands is basically a line that doesn't have to be employed by a dedicated staffer. They managed to potentially drastically reduce the number of required staffers via self checkouts. I say potentially, because 1 self checkout doesn't inherently equal one checkout clerk, but you get where i'm going with this. If my safeway can fire the 6 clerks i regularly see staffing the checkout lines, and hire 1 to monitor.. that's still a drastic layoff. And what about all the manual labor involved? I'm sure it won't be all robots stocking shelves, so mostly stockers can remain employed for the time being, but i'm sure at least a few employees who specialize in managing stock will be laid off as well. Just because it's not 100% layoff doesn't mean it's any less serious, imo. We're slowly decreasing the available job market simply put. Where are these people going to go?
- gremlinsinc 10y agoNot to mention the fact, back in the 80's/90's you go to walmart and every single aisle was open. Now pretty much any store I go to--there's maybe 3-4 open checkouts, and ALL self-checkouts are a go. Lines just are a lot longer, but it's not like people are going to stop shopping because of it. So they've cut a lot of jobs EVEN though there's a need for more workers at the registers
- srssays 10y agoI'm not saying that all retail jobs will go... yet. But the number of employees per store will go down, and since there is a large absolute number of retail workers, it will still be bad. Secondly, once people get used to shopping at stores where they don't have to line up to pay, the new experience will become expected by consumers. So there is a double effect whereby stores who adopt the new tech will save money on payroll, and stores that don't will lose some business.
- nickparker 10y agoThe advice part of a storekeeper's job is the easy one to automate. If we get rid of all the manual labor that humans do, why wouldn't we move the advice-givers to remote offices and improve their utilization? A call center to tell you where the milk is or which wine goes with your recipe might sound bad, but consider that you'd never wait another second to talk to a clerk, and everything would get even cheaper as more and more of the basic questions for the call center get moved onto intelligent bots.
- gremlinsinc 10y agoYou realize Amazon has an warehouse system run by robots, so there's a major flaw there..why do we need people to stock or work in a warehouse when that too can be automated? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=quWFjS3Ci7A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=quWFjS3Ci7A