4 ms·
Point by point. - If he has a recent model Macbook its KNOWN to be problematic. Searching "2016 macbook linux" most of the top results are about how it doesn'
by michaelmrose 10y ago
Point by point.
- If he has a recent model Macbook its KNOWN to be problematic. Searching "2016 macbook linux" most of the top results are about how it doesn't work well. He specifically says he assumed because redhat offered it that it worked with linux. When you can't spend 30 seconds researching your development machine it might be your fault.
- Server guis are known to be limited, hard to automate and just generally inefficient desiring a gui for your server is normally a sign that you just aren't very good.
- Users don't have to use ANY command line package managers there is in fact a gui for that if they prefer. If they choose wholly of their own accord to use a command line package manager they probably ought to read the relevant help document https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Package_management_system https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Package_management_system which makes the usage of the relevant tools pretty clear.
I don't think its untoward that red hat employees that wish to set up Fedora servers be expected to read documentation.
- legulere 10y ago> a sign that you just aren't very good. Another attack on users, this time pretty direct. I won't discuss the other points as it's again just shifting blame. The reality is that with Desktop Linux there's nobody taking responsibility that things actually work.
- michaelmrose 10y agoYou mean you wont address them because you cannot I presume? The critique is aimed at desktop Linux as a whole but is 99% is about how fedora works on his particular known to be problematic hardware. Fedora is first of all an unstable test bed for a commercial product running on hardware known to be problematic and the user is a red hat developer. I realized I had more useful things to do than beta test rhel in 2011 and I started buying hardware that works well with linux in 2003. Not knowing to how do this is certainly a forgivable thing in joe random business user but it becomes ridiculous when we are talking about a red hat dev. If a device doesn't work with its target platform be it windows, Linux, or mac you blame the oem. In this case whose job do you imagine is it to donate free labor to a multi billion dollar juggernaut to ensure their machines work well with Linux? Given the benefit Apple has derived from open source software it would be nice if they would help but they certainly have no real obligation nor do open source devs whose time is inherently a limited resource. In the end Linux has plenty of room for improvement but supporting everyone's hardware for free with finite dev resources just isn't a rational or achievable goal and lampooning linux as a whole because fedora doesn't work on your mac isn't even useful dialogue. Rational actors will react to this by reasonably picking hardware that is known to be well supported. Irrational actors will continue to complain on the Internet.
- legulere 10y agoI can, but I don't think it's worth my time, you will just counter those and pass the blame further. The first machine he had problems with was a 2009 mac mini. The second machine was actually given to him by red hat, which is the biggest linux company. But all this driver stuff and everything breaking all the time is hardly a distribution issue, it's shared throughout all distributions. Why should OEMs work on supporting Linux when they sell their machines with other operating systems? That's just passing the blame. The problem is that Linux is touted all the time as an alternative that is supposed to be even better, when the reality is that lots of things are broken and don't work out of the box. Not even on the most sold laptop models, which are macbooks. > Rational actors will react to this by reasonably picking hardware that is known to be well supported. Irrational actors will continue to complain on the Internet. People that want to actually get work done and do not want to or can not fiddle around will not use Linux.
- jrnichols 10y ago> when the reality is that lots of things are broken and don't work out of the box. And finding a fix can be elusive, when often times the answer is "your distro sucks, use $OTHER_DISTRO" or "use Google." > Rational actors will react to this by reasonably picking hardware that is known to be well supported. But what about when you pick hardware that is supposedly well supported and you still have problems? Run into that more times than I care to remember.
- michaelmrose 10y agoThen your complaint is much more legitimate but instead of making a linux sucks post report the relevant problem to people who might be able to fix it, consider funding development to improve the relevant software, or roll up your sleeves and lend a hand. Nobody said linux or open source software was perfect.
- Hasknewbie 10y ago> but instead of making a linux sucks post report the relevant problem to people who might be able to fix it. Yes, do not inform potential users that they might be taken for a ride, don't mention that 7-years old hardware is not supported, or that Gnome3 doesn't even know how to switch back to the default display. I mean, we wouldn't want to have informed users am I right? You are pretty much making legulere's point: hush hush no criticism in public, and even if it is valid please report it quietly. So I assume you would agree if Apple or Microsoft had a similar attitude? (And no need to mention "yeah but with MS/Apple you paid, therefore...", paying entitles you to tech support, and we're only talking about informing users here.)