4 ms·
sometimes the action is not illegal, but it will still looks bad after discovery So, are we discussing ethics or legality? If Google's official policy is one o
by tremon 10y ago
sometimes the action is not illegal, but it will still looks bad after discovery
So, are we discussing ethics or legality? If Google's official policy is one of "we like to skirt the law well into looking-bad territory, and that is fine" then they really need to abandon their "do no evil" motto.
- FordPrefectAO 10y agoIt was abandoned long ago
- oh_sigh 10y agoHow is it skirting the law? It seems more like "We (like everyone else) like to win court cases we may be in, and engineers providing unneeded or unfounded legal opinions over email makes it harder to win cases" Your inability to understand this goes to OPs point about engineers not understanding law. I'm guessing you're an engineer(or at least - not a lawyer)
- sangnoir 10y ago> So, are we discussing ethics or legality? No. I'll make an analogy: Engineers hate it when sales make commitments on behalf of engineering. Can you not imagine how lawyers might dislike engineers making legal commitments? When dealing with people outside of the org, lawyers want from engineers what engineers want from sales - be vague and don't create obligations you do not fully understand. It is still perfectly fine for a sales guy to privately point out a bug - just don't shout it to the customer.
- onion2k 10y agoCan you not imagine how lawyers might dislike engineers making legal commitments I think it takes a lawyer to believe "pointing out when the company you work for is breaking the law" is the same as "making a legal commitment", as if laws only apply if you acknowledge them. I'm realise that is essentially how the world lawyers live in works, but I think it sucks and I wouldn't want to sign a contract that forces me to be a part of it.
- skybrian 10y agoMost people in most areas don't know the law, so you can't point it out, you can only speculate. Assuming you know the law when you never studied it is the problem. The idea is that you should be asking if something you think is questionable is legal or not. That's why companies have lawyers. It's about bringing it to the attention of the right people who can make the call and keep the company out of trouble, without saying something incorrect that you might have to testify about later.
- stuckagain 10y agoYou are being obtuse. The point is that an engineer can't authoritatively conclude that the company is breaking the law, so they shouldn't write it down.