4 ms·
This. People talk about various alternatives, but I haven't seen one. The requirements are pretty simple 1) Chat and group chat (persistent) 2) Simple file tr
by alkonaut 10y ago
This. People talk about various alternatives, but I haven't seen one. The requirements are pretty simple
1) Chat and group chat (persistent)
2) Simple file transfer and image posting in chat
3) Good quality voice calls, video calls and group voice calls
4) Apps for android/iOS with shared contact lists
5) Single application for all of the above (to enable a single group set, switching between group chat and group call with one button)
6) No server setup
7) Free or freemium on all platforms (With all features
1-5 in the free tier)
Are there any good alternatives? Is there even an alternative?
- waldfee 10y ago+ screen sharing
- tluyben2 10y ago3) Is not true for me though, it's awful mostly, but that's my pet peeve (all coders assume everyone else is on a 1000mbit connection as well all the time) and MS is really bad at making anything work on bad connections. Office 365 isn't even getting past the 'wait while loading' while Google drive/docs is completely usable when I have a bad connection (which is often). The software that was written for bad connections, like Whatsapp and Wechat, for me, have much better quality. But no video (which I personally don't need, but it violates your 3rd demand).
- londons_explore 10y agoWhatsApp has had video for a while now... I'm guessing on your slow connection the update is still pending...
- dx034 10y agoFor me, whatsapp video doesn't work at all. When I use it with my girlfriend (I have iOS, she has a new Android phone) her video has a real bad quality while I can see hers perfectly fine. Voice quality is good as well. Video quality is perfect on Duo and Skype and we're both on WiFi, so that's not the issue. Don't know if it's due to the geography (across countries in Europe), but I couldn't find a solution yet. Calls work fine as well. I'd love to get rid of Duo but have to keep using it as I don't want to use Skype on my phone.
- pawadu 10y ago> 3) Good quality voice calls, video calls and group voice calls In my experience, voice quality issues is almost always due to the people and not the technology.
- tluyben2 10y agoWell Skype just disconnects often and it takes a while to get back. While the 'others' don't have that as they assume the connection will break / is too slow?
- ciaranm 10y agoDiscord does most of this. I've entirely moved to using it for voice comms with people where I'm suggesting the platform. It's guest support is pretty robust, so just fire someone a link and they can dial in from their browser if they don't have the app. Call quality is better than Skype, there's separate persistent chat rooms too. I like it a lot.
- kawsper 10y agoI like Discord, but their interface leaves a lot to be desired. Their sign out button is hidden away, and I wouldn't have found it if it wasn't for this article: https://support.discordapp.com/hc/en-us/articles/209572128-How-do-I-log-out- https://support.discordapp.com/hc/en-us/articles/209572128-H...
- tokenizerrr 10y agoTheir tagline is "Free Voice and Text Chat for Gamers".
- ciaranm 10y agoYeah, they're definitely targeting that market initially - but I'm seeing communities outside that sphere start using it: https://facebook.github.io/react/blog/2015/10/19/reactiflux-is-moving-to-discord.html https://facebook.github.io/react/blog/2015/10/19/reactiflux-... It's not perfect, but if you're looking for voice, group voice, and group text chat, it's a great solution. Very, very simple setup, little overhead. It is missing Video and Screen sharing, though.
- Renzoroe 10y agoWhat about wire.com? I think it's a nice app with focus on end-to-end security.
- Hermel 10y agoGoogle hangouts?
- alkonaut 10y agoHangouts is not a bad idea actually. I think the chrome plugin actually makes it look like a decent desktop app too (?) I very much prefer not to have to use a browser window for chat/voice/video.
- marksamman 10y agoI switched to Wire a year ago and haven't looked back. It meets all your requirements, and has end-to-end encryption (based on Signal Protocol) too.
- ValdikSS 10y agoI tried to use Wire with Zhovner (the author of this article) and it consumed 2 full CPU power for a simple voice call. My laptop heated up to 83°C, Zhovner's laptop was also hot. That's pretty strange since Wire has only interface written in javascript, all the core things are in Rust.
- blunte 10y agoMaybe a Wire client bug... I've used Wire for voice+screen share, and my MBP i7 didn't heat up or make noise.
- lmm 10y agoDiscord lacks video calls I think, but it's good enough that it's displaced all the alternatives for me.
- mrbiber 10y agoRiot.im is almost there, together with e2e crypto, foss stack, server federation and bridges to slack, irc etc.
- mixedCase 10y agoRiot is a good alternative to IRC, Slack and other team/community chat systems. It's not an option for the international 1 on 1 most Skype users are used to. The closest option seems to be Wire, but I've yet to try it.
- wila 10y agoThere's also 8) the phone line to skype voip bridge 9) a static phone number for your voip that you can answer anywhere in the world 10) reasonably affordable subscriptions for the phone line to skype bridge. 11) Simple hardware you can use as a phone by simply logging into to skype I know there's alternatives, but it has served me quite well for several years and changing means having to buy new VOIP phones. Skype has its warts, huge ones, like very misleading errors. Just today I got an email: "Your Skype Number will expire on" even while it has auto renew set to on. Then after login it says "your skype number has been cancelled". No it has not been cancelled. What ended up being the problem was that the skype database no longer knew how-to bill from paypal. Even while it had used that for another subscription the other day. There was also no bounced payment, it just forgot. I knew when I read "cancelled" that it meant something else from earlier similar problems. Skype is quite messy and every time I get an email "Skype has improved XYZ" I do wonder what it ended up breaking. I know I should find an alternative, but as long as it sort of works... These type of security issues do make me wonder again though.
- misingnoglic 10y agoHave you tried Allo/Duo?
- discreditable 10y agoAren't those unavailable on desktop?