5 ms·
Old news is old? The author laments that couples behave as if the public is their motel room - yet this is merely a continuation of a pattern that has been the
by potatolicious 17y ago
Old news is old?
The author laments that couples behave as if the public is their motel room - yet this is merely a continuation of a pattern that has been there for ages. It used to be that making out in public is scandalous and lewd; it also used to be that baring your ankles in public is similarly scandalous and lewd.
This is nothing new - we've been becoming "less embarrassed" (to put in the author's terminology) for years and years, well before the social media/reality show craze, and it will continue well after social media and reality shows have gone.
Social acceptability changes by geography and time - the author mentions the coworker who mentioned that he's shaved his whole body in preparation for a bicycling event... as a relatively young member of society, I see nothing wrong with this information. He has hair on his body that he had to remove - using means you're no doubt familiar with also - get over it?
- csallen 17y agoI have to agree that "get over it" is the correct sentiment here. This guy can't justify why his opinion on what's appropriate should count for more than everyone else's.
- SamAtt 17y agoI'm not even sure he's right His two initial examples, public grooming and public over-affection, are things that have been happening at least since I was 6 (actually I first saw someone putting makeup on in the car when I was 8 but I assume that practice existed before the first time I saw it) I'm starting to think the whole "Facebook-Generation" clap trap is more an invention of the media than anything else. Maybe it's just me but in my group of Facebook friends there are a few people who post everything they do and the rest remain relatively silent (generally only checking in when they think they have something funny and/or profound to say). The few people produce much more now that the tools exist to make it drop dead simple to do but it's still the same few people. It isn't like everyone just started sharing everything about themselves.
- jessriedel 17y agoThis is my anecdotal experience as well. It would be great to see a distribution of activity level for facebookers, and how much high-activity facebookers tend to associate with each other. My guess is that the low activity level of older generations is better explained by their unfamiliarity with computers than a lower threshold for embarrassment.
- jacquesm 17y agoThat could very well be a surprising revelation. After all, the more time you spend on facebook the less time there is for other activities, including association with others.
- jessriedel 17y agoThis trajectory has been going for perhaps a few decades, but human embarrassment is thousands of years old. So you can't just say "Oh, old people always think young people are too risque. Get over it." There is some structure to the current trend, and it seems worthwhile to try to explain it (though the OP fails, IMO). Now, that doesn't mean that the threshold for human embarrassment has been static since before the industrial revolution; looking at history, it has certainly varied dramatically across time and space. It's probably not random, so tracing it's cause would be interesting. Further, I don't think many people are going to go to the extreme relativist standpoint and say that all thresholds for embarrassment are equally (un-)valuable. It's not hard to make arguments for why it's a good thing people are too embarrassed to have sex in public (though I'm sure there are a few extreme bullet-biters). So then the question is, can you defend what you think is an optimal threshold for embarrassment, whether or not it coincides with the current threshold? The OP doesn't seem to be able to defend his, but that doesn't mean it shouldn't/can't be done.
- potatolicious 17y ago> " It's not hard to make arguments for why it's a good thing people are too embarrassed to have sex in public" Why? Not that I'd do it mind you - but that's a limitations in how I've been raised. When I think about it, there's nothing really objectively wrong about having sex in public.
- jessriedel 17y agoFor a reason related to, but not the same as, the reason sexual modesty evolved (which only exists in social species): because sex is a method to emotionally bond two people together in a way which is pretty much impossible to do otherwise because of the way humans are hardwired. This aspect of sex would be seriously diminished if it was routinely done in public because the participants would have their "social guard" up (that is, they would necessarily be concerned with signaling to others in their group/tribe). EDIT: Also, I should point out that your sexual modesty is more strongly determined by your genes than your upbringing. Sexual modesty is universal across human culture, even among people who have been raised in bizarre cults which tried to eliminate such modesty.
- astine 17y ago"the author mentions the coworker who mentioned that he's shaved his whole body in preparation for a bicycling event... as a relatively young member of society, I see nothing wrong with this information." I think that depends a little on the details provided. I wouldn't want to know whether your total body shave included your scrotum for example. Either way, you're right. I remember listening to people talk about having shaved for racing events long before the advent of 'social media.' I don't think that a lot has changed except for the subsiding of some of the formality of the workplace and a few other things.
- crystalis 17y agoIf the author's own conceptions of modesty prevent the accurate conveyance of the horrors (of shorn scrotums!) of immodesty, hasn't he proven his own modesty lacking in utility?
- astine 17y agoAre u`you saying modesty is useless because it prevents people from expressing immodest things? If that's the case I think you're confused. Discussing personal hygiene is considered immodest because people shouldn't have to hear about it. It's unpleasant, distracting, and completely irrelevant to most relationships. In other words, news about your scrotum is noise not signal. What should be considered modest and when, I think is a complex issue, whether some things should be kept private at least some of the time, I don't think is up to debate.
- crystalis 17y agoI'm simply saying, somewhat slyly, if a modest person expresses indignation over, e.g., tales of shaving, but their modesty prevents their audience from understanding why this tale could be reasonably offensive (i.e., the difference between "I had to shave my body for my race" and "I had to shave my balls and everything. You know that bit right there? Yeah, I think blah blah blah"), their modesty is doing them a disservice in making them look even more like a fuddy-duddy. More exaggeratedly, if a person's sense of modesty kept their ankles so well covered in warm weather to the point of heat stroke, their modesty has done them a disservice less modest people wouldn't need to deal with.
- ojbyrne 17y agoI immediately looked (in vain) for a reference to the poem "High Windows" written in 1974. When I see a couple of kids And guess he's fucking her and she's Taking pills or wearing a diaphragm, I know this is paradise Everyone old has dreamed of all their lives-- Bonds and gestures pushed to one side ... http://www.poemhunter.com/best-poems/philip-larkin/high-windows/ http://www.poemhunter.com/best-poems/philip-larkin/high-wind...
- mmazing 17y agoThanks for the link, I love coming across great poetry.