5 ms·
On the other hand, it's perfectly reasonable to remove some disruptive individual from a lecture (think someone repeatedly shouting the name of a soda in order
by maxerickson 10y ago
On the other hand, it's perfectly reasonable to remove some disruptive individual from a lecture (think someone repeatedly shouting the name of a soda in order to disrupt the lecture, not an invited speaker).
This is the same sort of removal of ideas from the marketplace that you are talking about, it's just probably not one you want to use as a test for what you have articulated.
- spikels 10y agoThere is a clear difference in these two examples. Trump tweeting does directly interfere with other Twitter users use of the platform while someone yelling at a lecture does. Twitter's attempts to "police" its users has been both a failure and damaged the reputation of the platform.
- cderwin 10y agoThe two are fundamentally different platforms. Twitter is an open space provided as a free service to the public at large, while a lecture is a fundamentally closed platform (only the lecturer speaks) only open to those enrolled in a specific class. That said, even in the example you give it is not always considered appropriate to remove people causing disruption. Consider, for example, a conservative speaker giving a guest lecture being protested against -- often loud enough the the lecturer needs to shout to be heard by his audience, even though protesters are outside. Here is a relevant video of Ben Shapiro giving a lecture at Penn State: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLpa6fsTxCA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLpa6fsTxCA
- rtpg 10y agoWhat about someone being disruptive at a open presentation? Or someone showing up to your local game meetup and being generally disagreeable? What about a public park that has gotten ruined because someone keeps on doing donuts with their motorbike on the grass? A library whose books keep on getting ruined by certain people? Even public services need to have some maintenance to not fall apart. There's a reason we call 4chan moderators "janitors".
- maxerickson 10y agoThe point of my comment is that it's an ideal rather than a principle. If you concede that it is appropriate to control the lecture space, you concede that it isn't a principle. At that point we are discussing the rules about when it is appropriate to have private controls on speech rather than our outrage at someone having a private control on speech.