3 ms·
Well, the same thing can be said about so-called fakes news--that it drowns out more objective, fact-based news, making constructive discussion difficult and ul
by wahern 10y ago
Well, the same thing can be said about so-called fakes news--that it drowns out more objective, fact-based news, making constructive discussion difficult and ultimately damaging democracy. So then what? It sounds like quite a pickle to me, without any easy answers.
Also, how can the government encourage censorship by corporations? Short of making laws regulating speech (which it cannot do directly, period, or even indirectly without strong justification based on a concrete need unrelated to the speech), it would need a carrot or stick.
The carrot would be something like tax incentives. Are you seriously worried Congress will use a tax give-away as an incentive for Facebook to censor news in a partisan fashion? I suppose it's possible, but so is my winning the lottery.
The stick would be using the threat of unfair regulatory scrutiny. Now this is far more plausible, but definitely not something keeping me up at night. And in any event, the solution would be to limit the ability to abuse discretion by rescinding regulations, removing discretionary authority, and/or making regulators more independent. That would be better overall.
By the way, this is why net neutrality is such a dilemma. It's a government mandate that has the effect of limiting the ability of corporations to effectively censor other groups by imposing transit taxes. But the mandate does that by censoring corporations--they can't chose to throttle, block, or otherwise differentiate communications from hate groups, etc.
Would you want to extend net neutrality principles to content publication platforms like Twitter or Facebook? What about your own bulletin board system? Mailing lists? How would you be able to block spam?
If your position is that all censorship is bad, and any law or market dynamic which limits anyone's freedom to communicate or not communicate as they please is bad, then you're just building a tower of dilemmas and paradoxes. The only way out is to deconstruct "censorship" into finer, more concrete concepts. In other words, avoid generalizations and discuss issues well within their context. And don't spread Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt by making recourse to poor rhetorical devices like slippery slopes (e.g. OMG if government or other powerful agents does this than that parade of horribles will happen).