4 ms·
"thousands of other companies employing many more workers" Ok so what's your short list of companies who employ roughly 250 thousand workers (and effect countl
by josefresco 17y ago
"thousands of other companies employing many more workers"
Ok so what's your short list of companies who employ roughly 250 thousand workers (and effect countless more) that could have used a bailout as well?
- modoc 17y agoWhat about a large number of smaller companies who employ the same in total? Or better yet, let companies fail, let the citizens keep their tax money to spend in the economy as they see fit.
- lenley 17y agoHow do you handle the World Trade model where foreign governments have no issue propping up their large industrial companies hit by recessions (companies that would also benefit from the decrease in your countries industrial capacity)?
- stretchwithme 17y agothat's their business. if they wish to subsidize the production of products so that we pay less, let them. It has never been a path to real success. all that sort of thing does is build up dependency on the government and an insulation from the actual marketplace. That is more GM's problem than its solution.
- notauser 17y agoIn the past it has been a path to real success, and consumers ended up paying more because of it. One example would be the Japanese electronics industry in the 60s-70s, which was subsidized until it broke the back of US competition. It then reaped a good profit for a long time before other countries caught up. (I doubt that GM could do this, at least not without a lot more money. But examples of "successful" subsidization programs to strategically promote industry do exist.)
- stretchwithme 17y agoI think they also had lower wages, statistical process control, concurrent engineering, the Taguchi method, the five why's, just in time manufacturing and many other innovations going for them as well. You can't say their success was due to subsidies without eliminating the effects of all of these other things.
- stretchwithme 17y agono one can use a bailout. my point was that we all need to be producing goods and services people are willing to pay for or go find something else to do.
- bmj 17y agoI find I can argue either side here. If GM closes a single auto plant, that does have a significant impact on that locale because so many people are out of work in a single stroke (see PGH when the steel industry died). 1000 small businesses shuttering their windows across the country still leaves quite a few people unemployed, but the ripple effects may not be as debilitating to each community.
- stretchwithme 17y agoWhen we make decisions and they don't work out, we must bear the consequences. We choose where to live and what work to do. Its a shame but its not a justification for making other people, who nothing to do with making those decisions, suffer the consequences.
- bmj 17y agoI agree--I was simply exploring another side to the argument.
- philwelch 17y agoCommunities are a means to an end. If a manufacturing plant town in Michigan loses a GM plant, let the people move out to other communities where they need to hire people. Don't tax successful communities to prop it up. We've had ghost towns in this country before.