5 ms·
My main concern with the hype around memristors is how quickly the technology will scale. Yes, they have great promise. But if technical problems make them 4
by btilly 17y ago
My main concern with the hype around memristors is how quickly the technology will scale. Yes, they have great promise. But if technical problems make them 4 times bigger and 8 times slower than existing technology, nobody will adopt them. And without volume adoption, they won't have enough investment dollars to be able to exceed Moore's Law. Which means that we won't care about them until well after Moore's Law runs out of steam.
This is not a theoretical failure mode. It has happened before in the computer industry. Multiple times.
For example it is why Transmeta died. Their goal was to have a simple chip that was so fast that they could emulate the x86 faster than the x86 could run. They failed. However one of the design goals was less heat (because heat was a major scaling barrier), which translated into having an emulated x86 chip that with much lower power. Given that they had a simpler architecture and had already solved heat problems that were killing Intel and AMD they hoped to iterate faster, and eventually win. But the investment asymmetry was so huge that they couldn't execute on the plan. And Intel was able to reduce their power enough to undercut Transmeta on the niche they had found, and Transmeta couldn't survive. (Intel was aggressive because they understood the strategy and the potential. Transmeta was always going to be something that either wiped out the existing industry or died with a whimper, and Intel knew which outcome they'd prefer.)
- reitzensteinm 17y agoDo you think their natural fit with FPGAs might be enough of a thin wedge to get them used at least somewhere? Or is the investment involved to get them performing better in even a field where they have a 10x or more advantage just too large?
- modeless 17y agoHP has already fabricated chips with memristors that are smaller, faster, and lower power than Flash. The problem I see is write endurance. They match Flash in this area as well, but that's not good enough. If memristors are to be applied to anything but storage (e.g. DRAM, SRAM, logic, neural nets) they will need to be many orders of magnitude more durable.
- hristov 17y agoIf that were the case, then HP should already be selling memristor memories to compete with flash memories. Flash is already a huge market, HP does not have to wait until memristors can compete with RAM.
- reitzensteinm 17y agoThese things take time. There are years and years between a single proof of concept working circuit and packaged product at Newegg, if it makes it there at all.
- modeless 17y agoGive them a little time; the paper was just published last month! Commercial availability is expected in 2013 according to http://www.technologyreview.com/computing/25018/ http://www.technologyreview.com/computing/25018/
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoI think you mistakenly believe that memristors must replace transistors completely for us to harness their benefits. memristors will start off like any other technology: in the special application areas where their cost/benefit makes most sense.
- sketerpot 17y agoOne of the reasons that people are so excited about memristors is that they're supposed to be able to scale better than Flash. When you shrink Flash down too far, you run into problems like having the electrons tunnel out through defects in the insulator. The limit is supposed to be about the 20 nm node. And apparently memristors are supposed to be practical to manufacture quite a bit smaller than that. And if we get the manufacturing techniques right, we'll be able to layer memristors in a fairly straightforward way.