9 ms·
"For example, Republicans are more likely than Democrats to say that the deficit rose during the Clinton administration; Democrats are more likely to say that i
by dnautics 10y ago
"For example, Republicans are more likely than Democrats to say that the deficit rose during the Clinton administration; Democrats are more likely to say that inflation rose under Reagan."
These are both really tricky questions, because the questions described are derivatives of derivatives! The deficit is the time derivative of the debt; so it's possible that someone is hearing "did the debt rise during clinton" (which would be true). Likewise, inflation is the derivative of the value of money. So someone might be hearing "did things get more expensive over reagan" (which would also be true). The deficit/debt one is really tricky since they both start with the letter D and even though I know the difference occasionally in conversation I switch the two.
- blowski 10y agoThe question itself is not important. The basis of the research is that one's political affiliations affect how you answer the question.
- convolvatron 10y agoI think it is* somewhat important as some of these political questions are very complicated and potentially very subjective. I think it makes a clearer case if they involved resistance to arguably objective facts.
- chc 10y agoThe point is that people tend to answer the question in a way that favors their party and disfavors the other party if you just ask them, but they're more likely to get it right if you offer an incentive to do so. This can't be explained just by "The questions are tricky," though that might be contributing factor that helps people fool themselves when they want to.
- smallnamespace 10y agoI'd offer that one issue with representative democracy is that the direct external payoff for voting well (by 'well', I mean taking the time to do honest research and keeping an open mind) is pretty much zero. That leads to a contradiction -- we expect our elected politicians to do whatever the public wants, but we also want our politicians to be wise, forward thinking, selfless, and moral leaders. Those two desires can only be fully reconciled if the public itself has those qualities, but the public doesn't have much direct, quick feedback as to whether it's making good choices. We also don't want to pay our politicians very much (politicians make orders of magnitude less than, say, business leaders) and still expect them to be fully independent, unbribeable, and only beholden to the public. You get what you pay for.
- DougN7 10y agoNailed it on the head! Everyone wants someone else to pay for services. Nobody is saying "Raise my taxes - I appreciate these services". We're all complicit.
- didibus 10y agoVery true. Coming from Quebec, Canada, I actually say that. It's more ingrained in our culture that what we are taxed for is services that benefit us all and that makes our societal environment more enjoyable. Now in the US, I can't seem to find anyone who think this. My biggest issue is that I can't even find anyone who thinks that the government is the people. Everyone seems to think of the government as this black box that has a mind of its own and inflict laws and rules upon us. While I'm much more used to the common thinking that the people rule, and the government simply enact our rule. We elect it, we pay for it, and therefore it simply does what we elected and paid for it to do. I'm not sure what makes up that difference, but it could be the bi-partisanery. It's a shame too, because it often fails to capture fine grain requirements. Like say I wanted a very liberal economy, while keeping gun rights strong and conservative norms in place? Or the other way around? There's no kind of choice like that. So you lysine end up for choosing based on your top issue only.
- kristopolous 10y agoIt's a pro-private, anti-democratic push by chicago school, objectivists, and other groups, to essentially slander civic institutions as terrible and "privatize" them with capital extracting robber barons. "Government" is a 4 letter word and some people are insufferable in their hatred for it - thinking that some private selfish interest of people would magically make the world ... look, it's all preposterous ... it's apologetics and denialism wrapped in the religious fervor of a mythical free market.
- lacampbell 10y agoThe issue is states trending towards the "mythical" free market have a track record of prosperity, while states tending towards mythical communism have a disastrous and bloody track record. East and West Germany, North and South Korea, Maoist Guangzhou and Unregulated Hong Kong. Time and time again it has been shown that a large collectivist state does not deliver on any of its promises, but instead creates poverty and misery. Now social democratic states can be relatively effective with a smaller population, and when administered by efficient, civic minded and hard-working people. The US Federal Government does not qualify.
- cabalamat 10y ago> they're more likely to get it right if you offer an incentive to do so The explanation for this is that people subconsciously keep note of which of their beleifs are Merit Beliefs and which Crony Beliefs. See http://www.meltingasphalt.com/crony-beliefs/ http://www.meltingasphalt.com/crony-beliefs/
- btilly 10y agoThey may seem to be really tricky questions, but they have really clear answers. Reagan was elected during an extreme inflationary period and it had dropped dramatically by the time he left office. Clinton started office with giant deficits and left office running a surplus.
- brownbat 10y agoInflation rose under Reagan every year. It also dropped every year. Just so happens it dropped by more. So if you just ask "Did inflation rise under Reagan?" A very literal answer would be "yes, repeatedly, just not overall." So you'd balk, "That's not the spirit of the question!" But let's switch to the spirit of the question. Suppose you know that Volcker's anti-inflation efforts are almost certainly the most decisive factor in the decline in inflation. Suppose you also know he was appointed to control inflation by Carter. And you know that Reagan later fired him for other effects of this work. So if we're going by the spirit of the question, it appears to the individual on the street to read, "Was Reagan the President most responsible for halting the inflation of the late 70s?" Once we're reading charitably and trying to make the question as sensible as possible, even then the answer is still probably no. The most literal or the most charitable answer is no. But, sure, asked to put money on it, most people would give the dumb answer too, because they'd assume anyone who asked such a poor question hadn't given the issue too much thought. Ok, ok. Postscript and time out. This is obstinate sophistry for the fun of obstinate sophistry. I wasn't of voting age in the late 70s and early 80s, and don't have a strong partisan opinion on combatting stagflation. But you could run this same sort of game on almost any one of these questions. It's not a clean world of pure facts that people are mucking up with their perceptions. It's almost all perceptions on top of everything. In fact, there's even a selection bias in the questions they pick, which have muddy expositions like this. No one just asks "Did Nixon visit China?" or "Did Johnson succeed Lincoln?" Uncomplicated facts are uncomplicated. Complicated facts only appear simple when you're giving the standard answer.
- nl 10y ago> Inflation rose under Reagan every year. > It also dropped every year. What does this mean? Are you just making a pedantic point that some months had higher inflation rates than others or am I missing something?
- azernik 10y agoIn principle they're 2nd derivatives, but in practice the public is only ever informed of the first derivative, rather than the plain value; news programs report inflation, not the value of the consumer price index, the deficit and not the debt, and GDP growth rather than the GDP. (To the extent that sometimes I've heard journalists and news anchors say that "GDP fell to 1% this year" - when actually it's "GDP grew at only 1% this year".)
- kisil_reboot 10y ago[With the acknowledgement that this is a tangent from the article]: I don't have hard data on hand, but in my experience, the kind of innumeracy you point to is shockingly widespread. Many people I've talked to do not know the difference between the debt and the deficit. Some people were shocked at the election results because they conflated 85% chance of winning with 85% of the votes. Of all the math classes I've taken, Dimensional Analysis remains the one I'd most like to see forced on every highschooler. Units matter. Unlike quantities cannot be trivially compared.
- zodiac 10y agoHmm, I think it's more accurate to say that the debt is the integral of the deficit. It's not like Congress passes laws to set the debt, then we examine how much the debt changed year to year and call that the deficit. Instead they pass a budget that exceeds (typically) tax revenue by a certain amount, and the shortfall (the deficit) is raised by borrowing money, which adds to the existing debt. You could argue that "the debt is the integral of the deficit" is equivalent to "the deficit is the derivative of the debt" but in that case, I could construct a well-defined quantity which is the definite integral of the debt starting from the year, 1800 and the deficit would then be the fourth derivative of that quantity.