4 ms·
"The experiments show that small payments for correct and "don't know" responses sharply diminish the gap between Democrats and Republicans in responses to "par
by ianai 10y ago
"The experiments show that small payments for correct and "don't know" responses sharply diminish the gap between Democrats and Republicans in responses to "partisan" factual question"
- narrator 10y agoThis study fails to impress me as anyone with some intelligence would always pick "don't know" since it's a guaranteed payment.
- alexbock 10y agoThey performed this with and without that payment. "This paper reports results from two novel experiments designed to distinguish sincere from expressive partisan differences in responses to factual questions. In both experiments, all subjects were asked factual questions, but some were given financial incentives to answer correctly. ... In our second experiment, we therefore implement a treatment in which subjects were offered incentives both for correct responses and for admitting that they did not know the correct response."
- throwaway729 10y agoBut if there's no payout then there's no incentive to say don't know. Whereas if there is a payout then the optimal strategy is clearly "dont know", assuming equal payouts for correct and dont know. Why would you take the risk of being wrong?
- hx87 10y agoQuote from paper: > The amount paid for “don’t know” responses was also assigned randomly, and was a fraction of the amount offered for a correct response: 20% of the payment for a correct response with probability .33, 25% with probability .33, and 33% with probability .33.
- throwaway729 10y agoThanks, that's exactly what I was looking for but it's hard on a phone. Qwrusz's comment may be relevant here.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jonas21 10y agoThe payment for selecting "don't know" was less than the payment for selecting the correct answer.
- __jal 10y agoI'm not impressed by things I don't read, either.
- alistproducer2 10y agoI disagree. If a person truly believed a bullshit answer was true they'd pick it over I don't know. The experiment shows that given an incentive to not think in partisan talking points, people will admit they know that what they would normal espouse as truth is, in fact,bullshit.
- tomjen3 10y agoOr, given an incentive people will answer with what they believe the other person wants.
- ghostly_s 10y agoPresuming the subjects truly believed their first-choice answers were factual, then why would they be under the impression the researchers want to hear something else?
- tomjen3 10y agoBecause they aren't dumb? The science man want to hear the science man answer. The priest wants to hear the priest answer. Granny wants to hear you like school, the cool kids wants to hear you think it is lame. Different people, different answers. Plenty of people learn what to say at what point pretty darn early.
- ghostly_s 10y agoRight, but how would they identify that "science man answer" is correlated with the truthful answer, without in fact knowing what answer is truthful?